Ghaziabad: A special Pocso court has acquitted a man accused of raping a teenager four years ago, ruling that the prosecution had failed to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt. The court noted serious inconsistencies in the minor’s statements, including her assertion that she had lied to police and the magistrate. It also did not accept her account that she had been confined in a single-room house for nearly 45 days, where she was allegedly given food only once a day and was not allowed to bathe or change her clothes.An FIR in the case was filed at Indirapuram police station on Dec 4, 2022, based on a written complaint submitted by the girl’s father. The complainant had claimed that his 17-year-old daughter went missing the previous afternoon and named the accused, his sister and brother-in-law for luring the girl. He claimed that when he visited their house, he could not find his daughter or the accused, but the two others threatened him with dire consequences.The initial FIR was registered under IPC sections 363 (abduction), 504 (breach of peace), and 506 (criminal intimidation) against the three accused. After primary investigation, IPC Section 376 (rape) and Pocso Act Section 5/6 (aggravated sexual assault) were added against the main accused. The chargesheet was filed on Feb 18 next year, and charges were framed on July 20.The prosecution presented five witnesses, including the girl and her father. The court, however, found substantial improvements and embellishments in the girl’s statement. The accused had maintained that the two were in a relationship and intended to marry, and that the girl had gone with him of her own accord.The survivor said that she was kept in a one-room house in a desolate place where she stayed for a month and a half without being able to bathe or even change her clothes. She also said that she was given food once a day, just enough to survive.The court, however, noted that in her statement under section 164 of CrPC, recorded before the magistrate, she had said that she went to the accused of her own will as they were in love and wanted to marry. They even went to the Kadkaddooma court in Delhi to solemnise a marriage. During cross-examination by the defence, the girl said that she had given a false statement before the police and the magistrate.“Her statement is not reliable, and as per Supreme Court judgment in Krishna Kumar Mallik vs State of Haryana AIR 2011, she is not fit to be declared a sterling witness,” judge Neeraj Gautam said in the Nov 13 order.The court did not find any medical report on record to support the rape charges.“The nature of the presumption against the accused under Section 29 of Pocso Act is not unlimited and the presumption against the accused is applicable only when the prosecution proves the fundamental facts relating to the offence. The prosecution has not proved the offence of aggravated penetrative sexual assault against the accused beyond reasonable doubt through oral and documentary evidence. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the above presumption is not applicable against the accused,” the court held, deciding to acquit all the accused of the charged offences.His sister and brother-in-law were also acquitted of the charges of criminal intimidation. The court ordered all three accused to execute a personal bond of Rs 20,000 each and two sureties of the same amount under CRPC Section 437A.
