Chandigarh: In a significant order underscoring an accused’s right to access official records required for his defence in criminal proceedings, the Punjab State Information Commission has directed the disclosure of a Medical Board opinion that authorities previously withheld as it contained third-party information.The commission observed that withholding the information could adversely affect the appellant’s ability to place relevant material before the competent court, where criminal proceedings against him are pending.Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and the appellant’s demonstrated requirement for the documents to defend himself, the commission held that the information deserved disclosure.State Information Commissioner Bhupinder Batth passed the order while disposing of a second appeal filed by a Mohali resident, who had sought information from the senior medical officer (SMO), Civil Hospital, Kharar, regarding a Medical Board opinion about an FIR and a cross daily diary report (DDR) registered at Nayagaon police station, Mohali.The appellant had sought certified copies of the final Medical Board opinion, the police letter on the basis of which the Board’s opinion was initiated, and all letters, notices and communications issued by the hospital or the Medical Board seeking his appearance.During an earlier hearing, the respondents maintained that the information pertained to a third party and could not be disclosed. The appellant, however, argued that the records were essential for his defence in criminal proceedings pending before the competent court.In his submissions, the appellant stated that the FIR and the cross DDR, both registered on Aug 30, 2025, were connected with a dispute between the parties. He pointed out that a Medical Board, comprising three SMOs, had been constituted at Civil Hospital, Kharar, on the request of the police and that the Board had submitted its opinion to the investigating officer on Jan 29, 2026.He contended that the Medical Board opinion was an official document prepared by govt doctors in the discharge of their official duties and directly connected with the criminal proceedings pending against him.During the hearing, a medical officer appeared on behalf of the respondents and produced the complete official record sought by the appellant in a sealed envelope, in compliance with the commission’s earlier directions.After hearing both sides and examining the submissions and records, the commission observed that the Medical Board had been constituted by a govt hospital following a police communication and that its opinion had been prepared by govt medical officers in the discharge of their official duties.While taking note of the respondents’ objection regarding third-party information, the commission held that the request deserved favourable consideration in view of the nature of the official records and the appellant’s demonstrated requirement for these in his defence.The commission also relied on a Supreme Court judgement, The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India versus Shaunak H Satya (2011), which explained that the objective of the RTI Act was to harmonise the competing interests of transparency and accountability with the protection of other legitimate interests.It, however, clarified that it was not expressing any opinion on the merits of the criminal proceedings, the correctness of the Medical Board opinion or the innocence or guilt of any person, as these matters fell within the jurisdiction of the competent court.Subsequently, the sealed envelope was opened, and the Bench examined the documents. The information sought under the RTI application was supplied to the appellant during the hearing.
