Bengaluru: A box of chocolates delivered in about 20 minutes for Valentine’s Day has ended up costing a quick-commerce platform far more than the amount the customer paid for it.Manju Prasad K, 30, ordered a Cococart Chocolate Gift Pack (Grand) through the Blinkit app on Feb 14, 2026. A few days later, after noticing an odd taste, he checked the wrappers and found that three of the six items in the box had expired on Dec 14, 2025. The remaining chocolates were close to expiry.Prasad, a resident of Hegganahalli Cross, complained to Blinkit’s help desk and followed up with an email on Feb 28. The company declined a refund or replacement, saying complaints had to be made within seven days of delivery. Prasad then approached the Bangalore Urban IV additional district consumer disputes redressal commission, seeking a refund, Rs 25 lakh in compensation, and Rs 15,000 towards litigation and travel expenses.Blinkit and Blink Commerce Pvt Ltd argued that the product page allowed replacement only within 72 hours. They also said Prasad had consumed the chocolates, leaving them unable to verify the product, and that the wrapper dates did not establish that the entire box was expired or unfit. They sought dismissal of the complaint, noting that he had submitted no medical records or bills to show he had suffered an injury as a result of consuming the product.The commission noted that the companies had given conflicting timelines, citing both a seven-day limit and a 72-hour limit. It observed that the box was delivered around 11.45pm, making it impossible to eat all six varieties the same day, and held that the Feb 21 complaint was within seven days of delivery. It also noted that the original wrappers were submitted as evidence and that the companies had not denied supplying expired chocolates, disputing only the delay in filing complaint.The commission observed that the issue was not merely about replacing the chocolate box or refunding the money, but about a seller stocking expired food products. It described mixing fresh and expired chocolates in a gift box as “highly condemnable”. It also accepted Prasad’s argument that this was done during Christmas and Valentine’s Day, when buyers were less likely to check expiry dates. The commission noted that Blinkit’s counsel did not dispute this claim. Emphasising the public health implications, it said many people in cities like Bengaluru relied on online platforms and exploiting their trust was unfair.Holding that the companies had knowingly supplied expired chocolates, the commission found them guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. The bench, led by president Vijaykumar M Pawale with members Chandrashekar S Noola and K Anita Shivakumar, on Nov 6 allowed the complaint in part.In its order, the forum directed both companies, jointly, to refund Rs 479 and pay Rs 3,000 as compensation for mental agony and hardship. It also imposed Rs 40,000 as punitive damages under Section 39(1)(g) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, to be remitted to the Consumer Welfare Fund.
