Bengaluru: Karnataka has asked Centre to review its E20 programme in consultation with states, backing its plea with lab tests that allegedly found excess ethanol in petrol samples.In a letter to Union petroleum minister Hardeep Singh Puri Wednesday, food, civil supplies and consumer affairs minister Rizwan Arshad said the state was not against ethanol blending but opposed over-blending.“The ethanol blending programme cannot come at the cost of citizens. A transition of this scale needs the whole ecosystem to be ready, including fuel infrastructure and ethanol-compliant vehicles, and that takes time,” he said.In his letter, he states officials inspected 63 IOCL, BPCL, HPCL and MRPL outlets in Sept. Samples went to labs of three public sector oil marketing companies (OMCs), which have so far sent reports for only 42, none stating ethanol content. OMCs told the state that research octane number was the compliance parameter, though they acknowledged that IS 17021 mandates measuring ethanol content. No reason was given for the delay in the remaining 21 reports.OMCs also questioned the sampling procedure and density. The state rejected this, saying officials followed Clause 8 of the Motor Spirit and High-Speed Diesel Order, 2005, and handed over sealed counterpart samples on the spot.Fresh samples sent to NABL-accredited labs showed wide variation. “Of 14 samples tested, 11 had more than 20% ethanol, the highest at over 31%,” Arshad said. The lowest was 13.5%. High ethanol was also found in premium petrol sold at Rs 120 to Rs 140 a litre.Arshad said inspections appeared to have had a deterrent effect and the blend may have since been corrected, but continuous checks were needed.He also opposed two central notifications on fuel dispensers. The first, dated Dec 18, 2025, doubled verification intervals from 12 to 24 months. The second, dated May 8, 2026, let private govt-approved centres verify dispensers, a job earlier done by govt inspectors. A legal metrology survey found 101 outlets dispensing fuel beyond the permissible error.Arshad said E20 needed urgent “course correction”, with adequate time and support to upgrade vehicles, fuel infrastructure, dispensers, storage and testing facilities. “Karnataka has placed all its evidence before the Govt of India and would welcome a detailed discussion at the earliest, so that together we can protect the people and restore public trust,” he said.Meanwhile, senior BJP functionary and former minister Murugesh R Nirani dismissed Arshad’s claim that petrol samples contained up to 31.2% ethanol, alleging that the testing methodology was flawed. He said sampling should involve representatives of fuel outlets, oil marketing companies, the state food and civil supplies department and Union govt. He also rejected claims that ethanol blending was intended to benefit Union minister Nitin Gadkari’s companies, revealing his own company produced 28 lakh litres of ethanol daily against Gadkari’s company’s two lakh litres.
