NEW DELHI: Supreme Court Monday said no voter or candidate had a right to demand reservation of a particular constituency for the SC/ST community, and govt’s decision to reserve a constituency could not be questioned if the number of reserved constituencies was proportionate to these communities’ population.The petitioners had challenged govt’s 2025 amendment to Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act, 1961. The amendment said the next general election would be treated as the starting point for rotating constituencies reserved for SC/ST communities.They alleged this wiped out the history of previous rotations and meant some constituencies that should have been reserved based on the earlier cycle would not be reserved.Advocate Vipin Sanghi said, “Introduction of a new set of rules, by itself, cannot furnish an independent justification for disregarding the previous rotation cycle where relevant electoral territories substantially continue to exist, albeit with altered boundaries, areas or numerical designations,”
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful ยท TOI community guidelines
A bench of Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana asked, “Do voters or candidates have a right to get their constituencies reserved for the SC/ST community?” It said, “No candidate or voter has a right to get a constituency reserved. What the rules provide for is that the number of seats reserved for the SC/ST community must be proportionate to their population in the state or democratic unit going to polls. It is nobody’s case that the required percentage of seats have not been reserved for the SC/ST community.“The bench refused to entertain the petition and said the amended rules conformed to the constitutionally mandated reservation policy. However, it allowed the petitioners to ask the appropriate authority to consider their representations.
