The Shenzhen trilateral summit may not signal a crisis for India but the government is closely following the likely outcomes, realising the meeting’s potential to alter several dynamics that it has to manage almost on a daily basis in its ties with the US, China and Russia.There was no official response from India to the “historic” 90-minute meeting that President Donald Trump had with his Chinese and Russian counterparts โ Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin respectively โ in China’s global tech hub but official sources said India is following the summit and likely ramifications with strategic caution.The meeting, which was described as positive and highly productive by the Chinese state media, ended with a declaration that committed to UN reforms, to deal more effectively with global challenges, stable energy flows, nuclear risk reduction and the “abuse” of its jurisdiction by the International Criminal Court (ICC) that issued an arrest warrant against Putin. India is not a party to the ICC and mainatins safe distance from it.Overhauling the UN โ with focus on expanding the Security Council permanent membership – and securing stable and predictable energy supplies have been core pillars of India’s foreign policy in a world marred by conflicts. Any indication of urgency for UN reforms is a positive development. However, there’s also little for India to believe that the call for the UN to conform to its “fundamental mission” of peace and security is more than just lip service. India holds P5 countries responsible for the delay in Security Council reforms and external affairs minister S Jaishankar has accused these countries of being “short-sighted” by not agreeing to any dilution of their powers.The focus on stable energy flows does provide some diplomatic vindication for its long-standing position that Russian oil purchase helped stabilize global energy markets. It’s also important that the declaration talks about expanding the production and supply of refined petroleum products, as India emerges as a crucial processing hub, refining Russian crude. For India, any potential easing of the rigid US position on India’s energy policy would be a welcome development.The statement that in the declaration shunning nuclear war also aligns with India’s core nuclear doctrine. India had welcomed the same formulation in a P5 2022 joint statement, saying that it creates a security environment conducive to global disarmament.Looking ahead, there are concerns that India might have about the likely implications from the meeting, and the answers to which might lie in doubling down on its strategic autonomy and multi alignment. Despite its time-tested ties with Russia, a great power cartel or a G3 that operates as an exclusive club to manage global affairs may not sit easily with India’s focus on a multipolar world and multipolar Asia or its efforts to lead the Global South into a decision-making role.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful ยท TOI community guidelines
There was no direct mention of the wars in West Asia and Ukraine where India is keen to support early resolution and has even put forward a proposal for safety of commercial shipping, while working to secure shipping lanes also in the Strait of Hormuz. India has argued that the Global South cannot remain a helpless spectator and must have a role in shaping peaceful settlements of conflicts that have most impacted the developing world.While much has been made about the US signalling to China through the Manila Quad summit, India realizes it must remain vigilant against the consequences of a US-China accommodation. Any understanding between Washington and Beijing that upsets the Indo-Pacific balance may not be in India’s interest. Even the Quad summit took place after 2 years and only on the margins of a multilateral event.
