Pay compensation and refund charges for deed delay, Haryana Rera tells Vatika | Gurgaon News


Pay compensation and refund charges for deed delay, Haryana Rera tells Vatika
The buyers said they had paid the stamp duty, but the developer still did not execute the deed

Gurgaon: Vatika One On One and Vatika Ltd have been ordered to refund escalation and maintenance charges collected from two buyers of a commercial unit in the city and pay Rs 2.5 lakh in compensation for failing to execute a conveyance deed despite a Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRera) order and grant of an occupation certificate in 2021.In an Oct 16 order, adjudicating officer Rajender Kumar ruled on a complaint filed by Apurv Sharma and Anant Sharma, who had booked a 500 sq ft unit at Vatika One On One project in Sector 16 in March 2016. They paid Rs 43 lakh as full advance, and the buyer’s agreement was executed in May 2016.According to the complainants, the developer paid monthly assured returns from April 2016 to August 2018 and then stopped. In an earlier complaint decided on Nov 21, 2025, Rera had directed the developer to pay assured returns at Rs 151.6 per sq ft per month till the occupation certificate was issued on Sept 6, 2021, and Rs 130 per sq ft thereafter for up to three years or until the unit was leased, whichever was earlier. The developer was also directed to execute the conveyance deed within three months of making a final offer of possession.The buyers said they had paid the stamp duty, but the developer still did not execute the deed. The adjudicating officer noted that the occupation certificate was not disputed and that Section 17(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, requires a promoter to execute the deed within three months of the certificate. Failure to do so makes the promoter liable under Section 18(3), he said.The officer observed that although the developer had not gained any unfair advantage from the delay, the buyers were entitled to compensation. He awarded Rs 1 lakh on a notional basis and said the complainants could approach the authority again if the conveyance deed was not executed within three months of the order.The buyers had also challenged escalation charges of Rs 1,080 per sq ft, which they said were not provided for in the buyer’s agreement, as well as maintenance charges levied before possession. The officer accepted both objections. He said a promoter cannot levy maintenance charges until possession, whether physical or notional, is handed over. Since the unit was to be leased on the buyers’ behalf, the date of lease could be treated as the date of notional possession. Vatika was directed to refund both amounts with 11% annual interest from the dates of collection.The officer also awarded Rs 1 lakh for mental agony, against Rs 10 lakh sought, and Rs 50,000 as litigation costs, against a claim of Rs 3.20 lakh. The buyers’ claims for 6% compensation on the amount paid, based on an appellate tribunal order that was not placed on record, and Rs 35,000 in travel costs were rejected. All awarded sums will carry 11% interest from the date of the order.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *