NOIDA: A Noida woman who suffered burn injuries and blisters on her back and legs after undergoing laser hair removal treatment ahead of her marriage has won a 15-year legal battle against a hair and skin clinic. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed the clinic to refund Rs 99,000, with 6% annual interest, and pay Rs 50,000 in compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.President Anil Kumar Pundir and member Anju Sharma, in an order dated Nov 4, held Berkowits Hair and Skin Clinic, Sector 18, Noida, and its proprietor Seema Goel guilty of deficiency in service. The clinic has been directed to make the payment within 30 days.The complaint was filed on Dec 12, 2013, by the woman through her mother, Santosh Redu, alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practices.According to the complaint, the woman approached the clinic after seeing its advertisements, seeking permanent hair removal ahead of her marriage, scheduled for Sep 9, 2011. She was assured that the treatment would be completed in four to six months through six or seven sittings, under the supervision of doctors and experienced laser technicians. The total cost was Rs 99,000, which she paid in three instalments.She underwent her first session on Feb 2, 2011, and was told that results would become visible after two or three sittings. However, during her third session on May 22, she experienced severe burning sensations, pain and itching on her back and legs. She subsequently developed burn marks and blisters.When she reported the injuries, clinic staff allegedly advised her to apply skin creams. A dermatologist examined her on May 25 and prescribed medication for seven days.The woman told the commission that the injuries, allegedly caused by excessive exposure to laser rays, disrupted her marriage preparations and forced her to postpone the wedding. She also said she had to bear the cost of subsequent medical treatment.She later approached the chief medical officer (CMO), Noida, who examined her injuries and concluded that they were caused by overexposure to laser rays. Despite repeated calls and emails, the clinic allegedly refused to refund the treatment charges.Clinic denies negligenceIn its written reply, the clinic denied the allegations and argued that the complaint of medical negligence was not supported by an expert opinion from a competent doctor or medical board.It claimed that the woman had been attended to by Dr Shimpy Singh at its Noida branch on Jan 2, 2011, when potential complications, including skin irritation, itching and burns, were explained to her. She paid the first instalment of Rs 50,000 that day and signed an informed-consent form, the clinic said.The clinic added that details of the treatment and the body parts covered were recorded in her treatment history, which she signed. The remaining instalments were paid on March 27 and May 1, which, it claimed, indicated her satisfaction with the treatment.It further argued that the technician had repeatedly checked whether the laser intensity was bearable, but the woman believed higher intensity would produce better results and said she could tolerate it.The clinic claimed she was advised to apply an ointment called Fusibet and use ice on the affected areas in case of burns or irritation, but did not follow the instructions.Maintaining that the treatment was administered with due care and in accordance with medical standards, the clinic said no expert had established any lapse on its part. It also cited its 25 years of experience and claimed to have served more than three lakh customers through a panel of dermatologists and BHMS doctors.Commission finds clinic deficient in serviceAfter examining the documents and arguments, the commission observed that the clinic’s own version showed that the third session was conducted by a laser technician. However, it had produced no evidence to establish that a qualified dermatologist was physically present and supervising the procedure throughout.The commission rejected the clinic’s argument that the woman had repeatedly said she could tolerate the laser intensity, calling it self-serving and uncorroborated. It observed that even if she had made such statements, the clinic remained responsible for monitoring her condition during the procedure.The panel also noted that the technician continued the treatment despite her complaints, while the doctor examined her only after burn marks and blisters had developed.“This conduct falls short of the standard of care expected of a clinic offering laser treatment and constitutes deficiency in service,” the commission held.It also rejected the clinic’s reliance on the informed-consent form, observing that consent to the known risks of a procedure did not absolve a clinic of responsibility for negligent treatment.“A patient may consent to the inherent risk of a procedure, but not to injury caused by failure to monitor the procedure, excessive exposure, or continuation of treatment despite complaints of burning,” the commission said.
