Gurgaon: Restaurants cannot automatically add service charges to bills or compel customers to pay them, a consumer panel has ruled while asking a city restaurant to pay Rs 31,000 in compensation and litigation expenses to a customer. The restaurant had refused to remove a 10% service charge from the customer’s dinner bill despite her objection. District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (DCDRC) also ordered the restaurant to refund the Rs 401 service charge with 9% annual interest, holding that forcing customers to pay such charges amounts to an “unfair trade practice”. The case relates to an incident on May 16, when the complainant — Aarti S Jain, a Sector 14 resident — went for dinner with her friends at Koca, operated by Luxe Sphere Hospitality, on Golf Course Road.DCDRC said the charge is voluntary and entirely at the consumer’s discretion under the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) guidelines. “Any additional compulsory charge amounts to an unfair trade practice,” said the order. DCDRC president Sanjeev Jindal and members Jyoti Siwach and Khushwinder Kaur directed the restaurant to refund Rs 401 with 9% annual interest from May 29, the date of filing the complaint, pay Rs 20,000 as compensation for mental harassment, pain and agony and economic loss and another Rs 11,000 towards litigation expenses. “From the aforesaid discussions, it becomes crystal clear that the opposite party in the present case not only committed a severe deficiency in service, but also adopted an unfair trade practice in a blatant violation of the above-mentioned guidelines,” the commission observed.Advocate Ritika, who represented the complainant, said the restaurant has been given 45 days from the uploading of the order, after the expiry of 24 hours, to make the payment. Failure to comply will attract 12% annual interest on the awarded amount until realisation. The commission warned that non-compliance could invite execution proceedings under Section 71 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and prosecution under Section 72, which provides for imprisonment of up to three years, a fine of up to Rs 1 lakh, or both. The restaurant was proceeded against ex parte and no defence arguments were recorded on behalf of the restaurant.After the meal, Jain found that the restaurant had added a 10% service charge of Rs 401 to the bill of Rs 4,811. She asked the restaurant to remove the charge, but it refused. “Left with no option, I paid the entire bill, including the disputed amount, and subsequently approached the consumer commission alleging unfair trade practice,” she said.Examining the bill and the CCPA guidelines issued on July 4, 2022, the commission noted that restaurants cannot impose service charges by default or collect them under any other name. They are also required to clearly inform customers that payment of service charge is voluntary and optional. No consumer can be forced to pay it or denied services for refusing to do so. DCDRC observed that the price of food and beverages already includes the service component and that placing an order implies consent to pay the menu price along with applicable taxes.
