Chandigarh: The Punjab and Haryana high court has held that a former Indian Navy official, who joined the armed forces before the proclamation of the first National Emergency in 1962, was entitled to the benefit of military service rendered during the emergency period for the purpose of increments and consequential pension benefits.Allowing a writ petition filed by Sakattar Singh, Justice Kuldeep Tiwari set aside a Punjab govt order issued in 2000. The order had declined the petitioner the benefit under the Punjab Govt National Emergency (Concession) Rules, 1965. The court directed the state to count the period of actual military service he rendered during the National Emergency.The high court clarified that a person who joined military service before the declaration of emergency would also be entitled to the benefit of service rendered during the emergency period.The petitioner had joined the Indian Navy as a telegraphist on July 7, 1960, and served until July 6, 1970. Thereafter, he worked as an ad hoc lecturer in English at various govt colleges before being appointed as a regular lecturer in the subject through the Punjab Public Service Commission on July 30, 1976.While serving in the Navy, the petitioner completed his graduation in 1966 and post-graduation in English in 1970 from Panjab University.Senior advocate G S Bal, appearing for the petitioner, relied upon the full bench judgement of the high court in Jang Singh and others versus state of Punjab and others, submitting that persons who joined military service before the proclamation of National Emergency on Oct 26, 1962, were also entitled to the benefit of military service for seniority, increments, re-fixation of salary and other admissible allowances under the 1965 Rules.The petitioner’s counsel also relied upon Rule 4 (i) (iii) of the 1965 Rules to contend that the petitioner was entitled to the benefit, which had been denied without assigning any reason.Opposing the petition, the state submitted that the benefit under Rule 4 could not be extended to the petitioner because he served as a Class-III employee in the Navy and that service could not count toward a higher-status Class-I post of lecturer.The counsel for the state, Karunesh Kaushal, additional attorney general, Punjab, also contended that the benefit of military service under the 1965 Rules could only extend to persons who joined military service after being influenced by the first emergency, and not to those who joined the armed forces as a career before its proclamation.Kaushal further argued that a gap of more than six years existed between the petitioner’s discharge from the Navy and his regular appointment as a lecturer, which was not condonable under the applicable rules.After examining the provisions of the 1965 Rules and the earlier judicial pronouncements, the high court referred to the full bench judgement in the Jang Singh case, which held that persons who joined military service during the emergency period would be entitled to the benefit of their entire service, while those who opted for the armed forces as a career would be entitled only to the benefit of the emergency period alone.The court also referred to a 2010 division bench judgement in State of Punjab and others versus Malkit Singh, which held that the benefit of military service during the emergency period must be granted even to those who joined the armed forces before the emergency was declared.Rejecting the state’s reliance on the 1968 Rules, Justice Tiwari observed, “Learned counsel for the state has wrongly placed reliance upon the Rules of 1968, as the petitioner has not claimed any benefit under the said Rules.”The high court further observed, “Furthermore, these Rules do not apply in the case at hand as the petitioner was not recruited against any reserved post under the Rules of 1968.”The court noted that the petitioner had not claimed that the intervening gap period should count toward military service and had restricted his claim to the period actually rendered during the emergency.It held that the petitioner was entitled to the limited benefit under Rule 4 of the 1965 Rules, only to the extent of increments, as he had already retired from service.“Accordingly, the impugned order is set aside, and the instant writ petition is partially allowed,” the court ordered.The state was directed to count the period of actual military service the petitioner rendered during the National Emergency when extending the benefit under Rule 4 of the 1965 Rules and any other consequential pension benefits.
