Headlines

HC penalises Belagavi resident for abuse of process of law by filing fake habeas corpus plea | Bengaluru News


HC penalises Belagavi resident for abuse of process of law by filing fake habeas corpus plea

Bengaluru: Karnataka High Court has imposed a cost of Rs 5,000 on a Belagavi resident for abuse of the process of law by filing a habeas corpus petition alleging kidnap and ransom of his brother, though the brother was living separately with his classmate at Dharwad.Amar Laxman Rayamane had filed a habeas corpus petition alleging that his brother Akash, an MBA graduate, had been kidnapped by some persons and that they were demanding Rs 50 lakh as ransom in lieu of his release.Following issuance of notice, the Market police, Belagavi, produced Akash along with one Priyanka. Akash told the court that he was neither kidnapped nor kept under illegal detention and, in fact, he was living with Priyanka for the past one year.Considering his submission, Amar informed the court that he would like to withdraw the petition.However, the high court did not like the petitioner’s conduct and pointed out that a petition seeking a writ of habeas corpus cannot be set in motion casually or as a matter of course.A writ of habeas corpus is an extraordinary remedy intended to secure the release of a person from unlawful detention. It cannot be invoked on the basis of allegations that are not substantiated by the facts, nor can it be used as an instrument to settle personal or family disputes. Two consenting adults have the right to choose their partners and live together in accordance with their own free will, and such a choice is protected under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, a division bench of Justices M Nagaprasanna and Hema Kulkarni noted.In the present case, it is alleged that the petitioner had knowledge of the detenue’s (Akash’s) whereabouts through a telephone conversation with the detenue, even before approaching the police. Despite having such knowledge, the petitioner is stated to have suppressed this material fact and instituted the present petition alleging kidnapping for ransom. Upon the detenue being traced and produced before this court, the allegations of unlawful detention were not substantiated, the bench added.The material placed before this court indicates that the matter arose out of a personal and family dispute concerning the detenue’s relationship with Priyanka. By invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of this court on the basis of the aforesaid allegations, the petitioner set the police machinery in motion, resulting in searches at several police stations and the examination of CCTV footage at various locations. This exercise entailed the deployment of public resources that could otherwise have been utilised for investigating genuine cases requiring police intervention, the bench noted.A litigant who approaches this court with unclean hands and suppresses material facts is not entitled to discretionary relief. The abuse of the process of the court, particularly where it results in the unnecessary deployment of public resources, must be discouraged. In the circumstances of the present case, the imposition of costs is warranted, the division bench observed while imposing the cost, which is payable to District Legal Services Authority, Dharwad.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *