Gurgaon: The district consumer forum has ordered a restaurant to pay a customer Rs 31,098 for refusing to serve regular drinking water and forcing him to buy two bottled waters for Rs 98. Holding that an eatery cannot compel customers to pay for something they never wanted, the forum termed the restaurant’s conduct a “severe deficiency in service” and an unfair trade practice.The district consumer disputes redressal commission asked Kafila Court Parking, near Rajiv Chowk, to refund the Rs 98 charged for two 500 ml bottles, pay Rs 20,000 compensation for mental harassment and economic loss, and Rs 11,000 towards litigation expenses.Mohit Jain, a resident of Jawahar Nagar, had visited the restaurant with his family for dinner on March 8. He told the commission that he specifically asked for regular drinking water, but the staff refused, insisting that only bottled water was served. Left with no alternative, he bought two bottles for Rs 98. The dinner bill totalled Rs 916.Jain argued that restaurants were required to provide safe drinking water and could not force customers to purchase packaged water. He approached the commission, alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.Examining the bill and Central Consumer Protection Authority’s guidelines issued on July 4, 2022, the commission observed that charging consumers beyond the prices displayed on menus, along with applicable taxes, could amount to an unfair trade practice. It held the restaurant guilty of violating the guidelines.The bench headed by president Sanjeev Jindal, with members Jyoti Siwach and Khushwinder Kaur, ordered 9% annual interest on the Rs 98 refund from March 13, when the complaint was filed, until payment.The restaurant must pay the amount within 45 days. Any delay will attract 12% annual interest on the awarded amount. The commission warned that non-compliance could lead to execution proceedings and prosecution under Section 72 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which provides for imprisonment, a fine or both.
