Ahmedabad: An accused govt employee cannot claim travelling allowance (TA) from govt to attend criminal court hearings in a corruption case merely because the case arose from the discharge of official duties, Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Ahmedabad, has ruled.Dismissing a petition filed by an All India Radio (AIR) employee, the tribunal held that provisions governing travel expenses for govt servants summoned for police inquiries or appearing as witnesses do not extend to employees attending criminal trials as accused.The case involved a transmission executive,who had been posted at AIR’s Bhuj station since March 2013. The CBI had charge-sheeted her in a case registered in 2009 after a complaint by the then station director of AIR, Ahmedabad, about events during her tenure in the city.Since she had to travel from Bhuj to Ahmedabad to attend the CBI court proceedings, she sought TA and requested that the days spent attending hearings be treated as duty.AIR initially sanctioned TA for attending court hearings. However, the department later realised it had granted the benefits based on an incorrect interpretation of the rules and, in Aug 2019, withdrew them with retrospective effect.Earlier, in April 2019, the CBI court had acquitted her of corruption charges. After the benefits were withdrawn, she approached CAT, asserting her entitlement to TA.The department argued that the provision allows TA to govt servants undertaking journeys to attend police or special police establishment inquiries in cases in which they are suspected of involvement, or to appear before a court to furnish information as witnesses. It said it doesn’t provide such an entitlement once an employee has been charge-sheeted and is facing trial as an accused.The tribunal dismissed her application, ruling that the initial grant of TA was based on an erroneous application of the rules. It observed, “An administrative authority is not bound to perpetuate an erroneous interpretation of a statutory rule merely because the error was committed earlier. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that an employee cannot claim a substantive entitlement contrary to the governing rules merely on the basis of an erroneous order passed by the employer.”CAT also held that the employee’s subsequent acquittal in the criminal case did not change the position, as attending trial as an accused could not be equated with appearing as a witness.
