CHANDIGARH: For a family that pooled nearly Rs 2 crore to set up a cloth retail business, the promise of owning commercial space in a project in Zirakpur gradually turned into a prolonged wait, unpaid assured returns and growing uncertainty. The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Chandigarh, has directed the developer to refund Rs 1.96 crore with 12% annual interest.The case began when six family members jointly purchased a commercial unit. Between Dec 17, 2023, and Jan 12, 2024, they paid a total of Rs 1.9 crore. They told the commission that they intended to establish and operate a cloth retail outlet.An allotment letter and an agreement to sell were executed on Feb 6, 2024. The agreement stipulated that possession would be handed over by Feb 6, 2029. Although the agreement set Feb 6, 2029, as the possession deadline, the family alleged that the developer had initially promised delivery within three years. A day after the agreement was signed, the parties entered into an MoU providing for assured returns.The family received Rs 2.2 lakh, after TDS deduction, towards assured returns from Jan 11 to June 2024, after which the payments stopped. The developer subsequently proposed waiving 50% of the outstanding assured returns, around Rs 1.1 lakh, and adjusting the remainder against retail space in another project, the family alleged. The buyers refused, saying their money had been invested specifically in the original project.Their concerns grew after construction allegedly came to a standstill. Photographs placed before the commission showed the building in an abandoned and deteriorating condition, according to the order. The family also pointed out that the project’s RERA registration was valid only until June 7, 2024, while the developer produced no document showing an extension. After their July 15, 2025, refund request was declined, the buyers approached the consumer commission.The commission, presided over by Padma Pandey with Rajesh K Arya as member, held that the family qualified as consumers as the unit was intended for self-employment, not speculative investment. It observed that although the contractual possession deadline had not expired, the stoppage of assured returns, lack of demonstrated construction progress and absence of proof of extended Rera registration justified the buyers’ decision to withdraw. The commission directed the opposite parties, jointly and severally, to refund Rs 1,96,75,547 with 12% annual interest from the respective dates of deposit within 30 days of receiving a certified copy of the order. It also awarded Rs 75,000 for mental agony and harassment.
