Ahmedabad: Mere failure to immediately explain the source of cash found during a search cannot make a govt official liable for prosecution on charges of possessing assets disproportionate to known sources of income, Gujarat High Court ruled while quashing a corruption case against a woman official.The case dates back to Oct 2014, when an Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) team, acting on a tip-off, searched a private car at Dr Jivraj Mehta Bhavan in Gandhinagar to catch an alleged corrupt official red-handed. The car was occupied by then Food and Drug Control Administration (FDCA) deputy commissioner Dipika Chauhan and her husband, who was also a govt employee.ACB sleuths recovered Rs 45,420 from Chauhan’s handbag and another Rs 30,128 from her husband. While her husband could explain the source of the cash and escaped prosecution, Chauhan could not immediately provide a satisfactory explanation. The ACB subsequently registered an FIR against her under the Prevention of Corruption Act, alleging possession of assets disproportionate to her known sources of income.The prosecution argued that Chauhan’s inability to explain the cash, coupled with contradictory explanations offered by her, established a prima facie case of disproportionate assets.Chauhan approached the high court seeking quashing of the FIR. Her advocate argued that her monthly salary was Rs 65,246, while her husband’s salary was Rs 48,206. The combined income, the lawyer submitted, was substantially higher than the amount recovered from her. The inability to immediately explain the source of cash, therefore, could not automatically render it tainted money or attract charges of possessing disproportionate assets.Accepting her contention, Justice P M Raval quashed the FIR, observing that the prosecution had failed to demonstrate how the recovered amount was disproportionate to the officer’s known income, particularly when her monthly salary itself exceeded the cash recovered.The court also took note of statements by two witnesses who supported Chauhan’s explanation regarding possession of the money. It further considered two departmental communications through which complaints containing allegations of disproportionate assets had been shelved.Emphasising the requirements for establishing an offence of disproportionate assets, the judge said the prosecution must establish the nature and extent of the assets, the known sources of income and, crucially, demonstrate that the assets were disproportionate to those sources.“Merely on the non-explanation by the present applicant with regards to the amount she was holding during the raid conducted would not amount to offence under Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,” the high court stated in its order.
