Bengaluru: Karnataka high court has quashed a magistrate’s order summoning a Bengaluru head constable and remanded the case for fresh proceedings, holding that mandatory safeguards for public servants under Section 223(2) of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) had not been followed.Justice M Nagaprasanna partly allowed a petition by head constable Shivashankar, observing that criminal proceedings must follow the path prescribed by the legislature and courts cannot dispense with statutory safeguards merely because proceedings are preliminary.Shivashankar was posted at Bandepalya police station last year when complainant MD Anil Kumar organised a Karaga Mahotsav at Mangammanapalya. Kumar alleged that Shivashankar and two other police personnel used filthy and abusive language against participants, disturbing public tranquillity and causing nuisance.Kumar filed a private complaint, following which the magistrate recorded his sworn statement on Sept 25, 2025. On Dec 12, the magistrate issued summons to Shivashankar and the two other accused.Shivashankar contended that BNSS Section 223(2) required the magistrate, before taking cognisance of allegations against a public servant concerning official duties, to hear the public servant and obtain a report on the incident from a superior officer. He also argued that prior prosecution sanction mandated under Section 218 had not been obtained.Justice Nagaprasanna held that the defect was not the absence of sanction under Section 218, but the failure to follow the mandatory procedure under Section 223(2). The court said the special procedure prescribed for complaints against public servants over acts connected with official functions couldn’t be ignored, as doing so would render the safeguard meaningless.Quashing the magistrate’s Dec 12, 2025 order, the high court directed the magistrate to restart the procedure from the stage after recording Kumar’s sworn statement on Sept 25, 2025.
