Headlines

Bengaluru man suffers nose injury after Metro grab handle snaps mid-journey, breaks Rs 3,000 spectacles; BMRCL claims passenger put entire body weight on handle but fails to produce CCTV footage, consumer commission orders Rs 5,000 payout | Bengaluru News


Bengaluru man suffers nose injury after Metro grab handle snaps mid-journey, breaks Rs 3,000 spectacles; BMRCL claims passenger put entire body weight on handle but fails to produce CCTV footage, consumer commission orders Rs 5,000 payout
AI generated image used for representational purpose only

BENGALURU: A routine Metro commute turned painful for a 49-year-old Bengaluru man when a grab handle inside a crowded train snapped and struck him on the nose, leaving him bleeding and damaging his spectacles. After the Metro operator denied responsibility and refused medical compensation, he approached a consumer commission, which has now held Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Ltd (BMRCL) liable for deficiency in service.The incident took place on January 18, 2025, when MG Nagaraju, a resident of Ganga Nagar Extension, boarded a Metro train from Rajajinagar to KR Market using his Metro card. With all seats occupied, he stood holding a grab handle for support.As the train approached KR Market station, the handle suddenly snapped and hit him on the nose, causing severe bleeding. The impact also broke his spectacles, worth Rs 3,000, and nearly sent him tumbling inside the moving coach. Fellow passengers came to his assistance.After getting off at the station, Nagaraju approached the station controller to report the incident. However, he alleged that the official initially dismissed his complaint and allowed him to register it only after repeated requests.When he contacted the Metro complaints cell four days later, he was told that no complaint had been received. He further alleged that the station controller subsequently shouted at him and refused to cooperate.On January 24, 2025, BMRCL emailed him, denying liability for medical compensation. Nagaraju then filed a consumer complaint on February 10, seeking Rs 1 lakh in compensation, reimbursement of medical expenses and Rs 3,000 for his damaged spectacles.In its defence, BMRCL argued that it was a public utility company jointly owned by the Karnataka and Union governments, established to provide safe, affordable and eco-friendly transport in Bengaluru. It contended that the corporation should not fall under the ambit of consumer law.The corporation also maintained that the grab handle assembly, comprising the handle, Kevlar rope, spring and ceiling attachment, was designed only to provide light support and was not meant to bear a passenger’s full body weight.Citing CCTV footage, BMRCL claimed Nagaraju had held the handle with both hands and put his entire body weight on it, causing the Kevlar rope to tear. It argued that the incident resulted from the passenger’s misuse rather than poor maintenance.The corporation said all train equipment underwent daily and weekly inspections and that the handle was in good condition before the incident. It also submitted a job card showing that the handle had been replaced at 11.05am on the same day.BMRCL denied that its officials had refused to register the complaint. It also questioned Nagaraju’s claim for the damaged spectacles, pointing out that the purchase bill was from 2015. The corporation sought dismissal of the complaint, alleging a lack of medical evidence and an attempt to secure wrongful gain.However, the commission found that BMRCL had failed to substantiate its defence. Although the corporation repeatedly maintained that CCTV footage would establish that Nagaraju had misused the handle, it did not produce the footage before the commission.The commission also considered a photograph submitted by the complainant, which showed him holding the grab handle normally, with no indication of misuse.It rejected BMRCL’s argument that the handles were intended only for light support, observing that the corporation had not communicated any such restriction to passengers through signboards, announcements or guidelines.Given the overcrowding in Metro coaches, passengers could not be expected to know the technical limitations of the grab handles, the commission said, holding that the failure to communicate these restrictions amounted to deficiency in service.Rejecting the corporation’s contention that it was outside the purview of consumer law, the commission held that a Metro operator collecting fares from passengers qualified as a service provider under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.The commission bench, comprising president Syed Anser Kaleem and members Sharavathi SM and Jyothi N, on May 4 directed BMRCL to pay Nagaraju Rs 3,000 towards the cost of his broken spectacles and Rs 2,000 as compensation and litigation costs.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *