New Delhi: A Union health ministry exercise to review eligibility norms for doctors with benchmark disabilities across 54 medical specialties has drawn objections from doctors with disabilities, who say the panel overseeing the exercise does not include a practising doctor with a disability.In a representation sent on Nov 16, the group has sought their inclusion in the decision-making process, arguing that professional competence should be assessed on the basis of speciality-specific clinical duties and reasonable accommodation rather than physical limitations.The review, initiated after an expert committee meeting on Oct 22, will be undertaken by four Delhi institutions — Maulana Azad Medical College, ABVIMS and Dr Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital, Lady Hardinge Medical College, and VMMC and Safdarjung Hospital.Of the 54 specialities, 43 have been earmarked for identification of functional classifications and physical requirements for persons with benchmark disabilities while 11 have been assigned for review of existing classifications and requirements.The 43 specialities include anaesthesia, surgery, gastroenterology, ophthalmology, dermatology, pathology, obstetrics and gynaecology, paediatrics, cardiology, neurology, nephrology, oncology, orthopaedics, pulmonary medicine, rehabilitation, public health and sports medicine, among others.The existing classifications of 11 specialities, including anatomy, ENT, biochemistry, general medicine, microbiology, pharmacology, radiodiagnosis, psychiatry, radiotherapy, TB and chest diseases, and urology, will also be reviewed.Institutional subcommittees will assess the actual clinical, academic, surgical, emergency and diagnostic duties in each speciality, while considering whether assistive equipment, ergonomic aids, digital diagnostic tools and other technological advances can help doctors with disabilities perform these functions.The subcommittees have been asked to prepare speciality-wise recommendations, preferably within four weeks, for consideration by the ministry-level committee. The recommendations will subsequently be placed before the department of empowerment of persons with disabilities and the UPSC.In the representation, Dr Satendra Singh, writing on behalf of Doctors with Disabilities: Agents of Change, said the ministry-level committee did not include a practising doctor with a disability. He pointed out that representation from disability organisations could not substitute for the direct participation of medical professionals with disabilities who understand the clinical, academic and professional demands of individual specialities.The group has also questioned using physical activities such as walking, bending and climbing to assess doctors’ suitability, arguing that the focus should instead be on clinical competence, reasonable accommodation and assistive technology.Citing examples of a spinal cord-injured urologist and blind psychiatrists practising their specialities, the group has sought representation of practising doctors with disabilities on the committee and in wider consultations beyond Delhi.Govt minutes state that institutional subcommittees will include a doctor with benchmark disability from the respective speciality, wherever available.
