New Delhi: Enhancing by nearly three times to over Rs 4.2 crore the compensation awarded to an accident victim left comatose for life, Delhi High Court has stressed that “just and reasonable” compensation must be ensured by tribunals/courts where lifetime care has to be given to victims by family members.HC took a dim view of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal’s move to hand over reduced compensation — Rs 1.52 crore — on the ground that the victim, Bharat Ghai, an event manager before his accident in 2022, failed to file IT returns.“Despite having complete knowledge that the injured/claimant had been in a comatose state since the date of the accident… MACT proceeded to hold that the non-filing of ITR for AY 2022-2023 warranted an inference that the claimant did not have any taxable income during the said assessment year,” HC said, terming it “completely unfair, unjust and illogical”.Justice Anish Dayal stressed that towards the end of FY 2021-2022, the injured had been rendered comatose and, therefore, “in such circumstances, the family couldn’t have been expected to have gathered the claimant’s income documents and ensure his ITRs were filed in the aftermath of such a tragedy”.HC said in such cases of bedridden victims, compensation must factor in the average income reflected in their ITRs for up to three years before the accident rather than their reduced income in a particular year.“It is a settled principle of law that compensation under MV Act cannot be awarded on account of pittance. It is the duty of the court to award just and reasonable compensation. In cases where the injured/claimant remains in a comatose/vegetative state, quantification of compensation necessarily requires the court to make a reasonable estimation, having regard to the surrounding circumstances and practical realities, as the actual and future expenses cannot always be precisely ascertained or awarded on the basis of proved expenditure alone,” Justice Dayal noted.Ghai, 39, was hit by a car head-on on Feb 11, 2022 near BSF Camp, Chhawla, when he was helping his children step out of his parked vehicle near the roadside. He suffered severe hypoxic brain injury and has remained comatose and bedridden, with 100% permanent impairment medically certified as “not likely to improve”. The claim was pursued by his wife. His family includes two school-going children and an 80-year-old mother.Appearing for Ghai, senior advocate Sanjeev Ralli said MACT failed to take into account the continuous expenses incurred by the family.
