Chandigarh: A woman seeking transfer of a civil suit from Phillaur to Mukerian, citing difficulties in travelling alone and claiming that her father was sick and bedridden, has been denied relief by the Punjab and Haryana High Court after it found that her father had died 7-8 years before the filing of the application.Justice Mandeep Pannu observed that the woman had made a false averment regarding the illness and bedridden condition of her father, who was already dead at the time of filing of the transfer application, which constituted concealment of a material fact having a direct bearing on the relief sought.The woman had sought transfer of Civil Suit, pending before the Court in Phillaur, to a court of competent jurisdiction at Mukerian, Hoshiarpur.Counsel for the applicant submitted that the respondent, who is her brother-in-law, had instituted the civil suit for recovery of damages at Phillaur, approximately 120 kilometres one way from Village Ghaseetpur, Tehsil Mukerian, where she was residing.It was further submitted that another proceeding under Section 144 of the BNSS between the applicant and her husband was pending at Mukerian. The applicant was residing with her parents, her father was poor, sick and bedridden, and she had no independent source of income and was unable to maintain herself. It would, therefore, be extremely difficult for her to travel alone to Phillaur to attend the court proceedings.Opposing the plea, counsel for the respondent submitted that the applicant was gainfully employed as a nurse and was earning approximately Rs 30,000 per month.The respondent’s counsel also submitted that the FIR registered at the instance of the applicant under Section 498-A IPC (now Section 85 of the BNS) was pending only against her husband and that the respondent had not been arrayed as an accused in it.It was further contended that the applicant had concealed material facts, as her father had already passed away about 7-8 years ago and, therefore, the plea regarding his illness and bedridden condition was factually incorrect. The proceedings pending at Mukerian were between the applicant and her husband and did not involve the respondent, the counsel submitted.The High Court on hearing the matter observed, “It is well settled that a litigant seeking discretionary relief from the Court is required to approach the Court with clean hands and make a full and fair disclosure of all material facts. Suppression or misrepresentation of material facts disentitles a party from claiming such relief.”The Bench noted that the respondent’s assertion regarding the applicant’s father having died was substantiated by the wedding invitation card placed on record.“In the present case, the applicant has not only suppressed a material fact but has also sought to seek advantage on the basis of a factually incorrect assertion,” the Bench observed.“In view of the aforesaid circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that the applicant is not entitled to the discretionary relief of transfer. Consequently, the present transfer application is dismissed,” Justice Pannu held.
