Tamil Nadu Tribals Denied Forest Rights as Official Policies Fail | Chennai News


Tamil Nadu Tribals Denied Forest Rights as Official Policies Fail
Villagers say they are forced to hand over their produce to lower-level forest officers and vyaparis at low rates

Aruna Basu Sarcar & Manoj Kumar SarkarIt is ironic that as India commemorated its fifth official Janajatiya Gaurav Diwas or Tribal Pride Day on Nov 15, the birth anniversary of tribal freedom fighter Birsa Munda, his struggle against the exploitation of indigenous communities remains relevant. His ‘ulgulan’ or rebellion, challenged the exploitation of tribal communities in Chota Nagpur. His call for ‘jal, jangal, zameen (water, forest and land)’ resonates in Tamil Nadu, where forest-dwelling communities along the Eastern and Western Ghats face persistent struggles over land, livelihoods and rights.The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006, was meant to address historical injustices against forest-dwelling communities during the colonial and post-colonial periods. Yet, two decades later, many of the rights promised under the legislation are unrealised.In the foothills of Palani, members of the Paliyar tribal community have been denied scheduled tribe (ST) certificates for more than 20 years. In settlements such as Kuthiraiaru Dam, Puliyampatti and Ponthupuli in Palani taluk of Dindigul district, revenue officials have classified them as Puliyars, a scheduled caste community, despite being the blood relatives of Paliyars in Kodaikanal who hold ST certificates. Consequently, bureaucracy disqualifies them from claiming forest rights.The official hypocrisy is glaring. These settlements have benefited from integrated tribal development programme (ITDP) projects implemented by the forest department and are recorded as tribal habitations in govt-approved forest working plans. Yet, recommendations made by gram sabhas, which are empowered under the Forest Rights Act (FRA) to initiate and verify claims, have been rejected by the sub-divisional level committee, undermining the very principle of grassroots decision-making enshrined in the Act.The state’s tribal welfare department, the nodal agency for implementing the FRA, highlights its progress through the distribution of individual land titles. However, fewer than 20% of forest-dwelling communities have agricultural land, while the remaining 80% depend on collecting minor forest produce (MFP) for their livelihoods.These communities face restrictions on accessing open markets, with legal and allegedly illegal forest checkposts limiting the movement and sale of their produce. This continues despite central govt directions to states to ease forest transit rules in accordance with FRA. However ignoring these directions, the state has abandoned these communities to exploitation. Thus the self-reliant forest guardians turn into forced bonded labour on the land they have protected for generations.Who really owns the forests, ask senior forest officials in Tamil Nadu. Keep forest produce ownership out of tribal hands and the forest stays safe, they say. It is a convenient myth. Denying forest produce ownership to communities does not leave forest produce unharvested, but privatizes plunder, pushing the community into the clutches of middlemen, locally referred to as vyapari (traders). These traders are allegedly selected and approved by lower-level forest officials, who compel forest produce gatherers to hand over their collections to designated vyaparis at low rates.During a visit to Manthittu, a settlement of the impoverished Malai Malasar community, a young resident displayed his forest rights title (urimai) and explained why it had made little difference to his life. “The vyapari waits downhill, and when we return after collecting seemar pul (date palm leaves used to make brooms), we hand everything over to him. We cannot sell it anywhere else,” he says.This is how a policy ostensibly intended to protect forests can end up perpetuating the exploitation of the communities that depend on them as well as cause severe biodiversity loss. Massive harvest of nux vomica fruits in Javadu, satavari tubers from Palani hills, gallnuts from Shervarayan hills, kalpasi (black stone flower) from Melagiri and mavaalikizhangu (swallow root) from Pachamalai are a few examples of extraction that allegedly take place with little ecological concern.The question is why, even after two decades have passed since FRA was enacted, the recognition of community forest rights, which are central to tribal livelihoods, remains unresolved.Even where rights have been granted on paper, forest-dwelling communities continue to face exploitation through the parallel structure of village forest committees (VFCs). These committees emerged under the joint forest management policy in 1998. Although they are not statutory authorities, forest field staff working through VFCs allegedly prevent communities from harvesting and selling minor forest produce to which they are legally entitled under FRA. Large quantities of forest produce collected by tribal communities are reportedly sold through officials of VFCs. Only a fraction of it is recorded, with meagre returns deposited into VFC accounts. The remainder is unaccounted for.VFC funds have escaped public scrutiny since its inception in 1998, with no accountability of money either deposited or withdrawn from VFC account. Accounts are jointly operated by the forest ranger, who serves as VFC secretary, and a tribal representative appointed as president. However, the president is often an uneducated helpless member handpicked by forest officials and kept in the dark about account balances and transactions.In some areas, VFC presidents are reportedly made to organise tribal residents to harvest, pack and load produce for designated traders. While vehicles belonging to these traders pass through forest checkposts, tribal gatherers carrying produce on foot or bicycles face additional restrictions, including illegal checkposts that prevent them from reaching local markets.In several areas, forest dwellers are also reportedly required to pay between `4,000 and₹`5,000 annually to local forest officials merely to enter forests and collect produce, even when they hold collection rights.To uphold the spirit of FRA, Tamil Nadu must abandon this colonial conservation myth, issue overdue ST certificates, ban the participation of VFC in collection and sale of forest produce, dismantle the vyapari–official nexus and illegal check posts and amend forest produce transit rules. The need of the hour is for authorities in sub-divisional level committee and district level committee from revenue, forest and tribal welfare department to equip themselves with knowledge of processing forest rights claims.(The writers are retired Indian forest service officers)



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *