‘Suspicion not enough’: Court rejects Haryana judge’s plea to transfer bail hearing | Delhi News


‘Suspicion not enough’: Court rejects Haryana judge’s plea to transfer bail hearing

New Delhi: A Delhi court has refused to transfer the bail hearing of a cheating case accused after a plea claimed that the judicial officer hearing the case was “biased.” The accused had allegedly cheated a Haryana judge, who is the petitioner, of more than Rs 52 lakh.Principal district and sessions judge Vijay Kumar Dahiya said entertaining a transfer plea “without an iota of material, alleging bias on the part of the judicial officer” would make it impossible for judiciary to function “without fear or favour”.“Allegations of bias against a judicial officer are not to be likely made. Even issuance of notice on such an application has serious deleterious repercussions for the judicial officer concerned in as much as every judicial officer is expected to act without fear or favour,” Judge Dahiya said.The case relates to an alleged cyber fraud of Rs 52 lakh, wherein Delhi Police’s special cell had registered an FIR against Deepak Vats, whose bail application is pending before additional sessions judge Saurabh Partap Singh Laler. The Harynana judge and her household help sought transfer of the bail plea under Section 448 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. They sought an independent hearing before a different judicial officer.Their grievance stemmed from June 9 order rejecting Vats’s earlier bail plea. The Haryana judge contended that there were remarks alluding to the officer’s personal life and alleged relationship with Vats, and weren’t needed to decide the bail. The order had also questioned her approach as she reached out through her maid’s name, “rather than coming forward herself”. She said the order named her and highlighted her judicial position, affecting her privacy and reputation. Delhi High Court later stayed the observations and allowed her identity to be masked.In the transfer plea, the judge alleged that the order relied on unauthenticated WhatsApp screenshots, using generative AI, and that it omitted her counsel’s appearance, arguments and cited judgments.However, Dahiya held that none of the circumstances are sufficient enough to even draw an inference that the judicial officer is biased in any manner. “Mere suspicion or apprehension is not good enough to entertain a plea of bias,” Dahiya stated, adding that the circumstances must create an impression of bias in the mind of a reasonable person.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *