Jaipur: Eight postgraduate students of Jaipur’s SMS Medical College have written to National Medical Commission (NMC) alleging prolonged harassment, intimidation and discriminatory academic practices after failing the practical component of their final examinations while clearing their theory papers.The eight final-year students of the medical college’s pathology department have also written to the institution’s principal with allegations of mental harassment, biased treatment and unfair examination practices.The college, however, has denied all allegations, insisting the exams were conducted in a fair and impartial manner.In their letter to the NMC, the students demanded the removal of the head of the department (HoD) of pathology, Dilip Ramrakhiani, besides calling for an independent inquiry into the matter and a change of centre for the supplementary practical examination.Reacting to the development, the Jaipur Association of Resident Doctors voiced concerns over the transparency of the practical assessment process, claiming that such a large number of failures was unprecedented.The association demanded an independent and time-bound inquiry into the matter and asked for the HoD concerned to be kept away from administrative responsibilities till its completion.Besides that, it called for an independent review of the results of the practical examination, while seeking protection of the complainants from any retaliatory action. Finally, the association demanded that the supplementary practical examination be conducted by independent examiners at a separate medical college.SMS Medical College principal Deepak Maheshwari refused to comment on the allegations, while HoD Ramrakhiani denied all charges.“Practical exams are conducted in a fair and impartial manner by a team of four examiners,” Ramrakhiani said.“Besides the HoD, the team includes a senior professor and two reputed external examiners, this time from AIIMS, Delhi, and PGI Chandigarh. All four examiners make a joint assessment of whether a student’s performance is up to the required standards,” he added.“Eight students in a class of 29 failed because they were unable to demonstrate the minimum level of proficiency required. Singling out one person to blame for that result is not justified,” the HoD said.Resident doctors, however, alleged that the pathology department has been functioning in an atmosphere of fear, intimidation, humiliation and sustained mental pressure. They also questioned the repeated appointment of the HoD as an internal examiner, alleging it compromised transparency and impartiality.They further claimed that students who approached the HoD with genuine concerns were met with dismissive behaviour and mockery instead of support. They also alleged that students faced pressure to contribute financially for different departmental programmes.The association further claimed that the postgraduate exam schedule was itself responsible for disrupting the academic calendar. The exams, which were supposed to be held in July/Aug, were conducted in Oct, with results declared in Nov.Students who failed the practical exam will now have to reappear for their theory papers in Jan/Feb, with dates for practical exams yet to be announced.
