Guwahati: Union home minister Amit Shah on Saturday firmly backed the proposed 11,200 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) in Arunachal Pradesh, underlining its importance to India’s energy security and strategic interests, even as he sought to allay fears among residents of the Siang valley who are opposing the project.Assuring protesters that no decision would be taken without taking them into confidence, Shah said the Centre would pursue the project through positive and constructive dialogue.“This Siang project is a national project, which is very important from the point of view of Arunachal’s development, the country’s energy security, Arunachal’s budget, Arunachal’s income and strategic interests,” Shah said, making it clear that the Centre remains committed to the ambitious hydropower project.The proposed dam has acquired significance beyond power generation, with India viewing it as a strategic counter to China’s 60,000 MW hydropower project planned on the Yarlung Tsangpo at the Great Bend in Medog, upstream of the McMahon Line. The Chinese project has heightened concerns in India over Beijing’s ability to regulate the flow of a river that enters Arunachal Pradesh as the Siang and subsequently becomes the Brahmaputra in Assam.Speaking at Banderdewa after presenting the President’s Colour to Arunachal Pradesh Police, Shah said he had learnt about the concerns and sentiments of people in the Siang valley through media reports and chief minister Pema Khandu.In his first direct assurance from the Centre amid the growing agitation, Shah said, “I want to assure my brothers and sisters of Siang that we will hold positive and constructive discussions with you, we will take you into confidence, and the way forward will emerge only through dialogue. You do not need to worry about anything in this.”Seeking to address concerns over the possible impact on indigenous communities, Shah pledged that the project would not come at the cost of the Adi community’s traditions and cultural identity.“The respect that you have for your culture, I have the same respect, and my government has the same respect. Without compromising on this, we will find the way ahead with India’s most attractive rehabilitation package, and without harming your traditions, culture and religion by even one inch,” he said.Shah urged protesters to engage with the state government and the Union home ministry to resolve the impasse. “Hold discussions with the state government, and through the state government hold discussions with the home ministry too,” he appealed.“For the future of Arunachal, for the future of Arunachal’s youth, this important project, we will take it forward with positive dialogue. We will take it forward only after taking you into confidence, and I want to stress this point again,” Shah said.The assurance comes amid opposition from residents and indigenous groups in three districts — Siang, Upper Siang and East Siang — through which the proposed project and its reservoir are planned. The agitation has intensified ahead of the government’s attempt to conduct a pre-feasibility survey, with protesters questioning the need for a mega dam in a region they say is ecologically fragile and highly vulnerable to earthquakes.The Siang, known as the Yarlung Tsangpo in Tibet, flows through these three districts before entering Assam, where it joins other rivers to form the Brahmaputra. China’s proposed project upstream has added a strategic dimension to the debate, particularly in the absence of a binding water-sharing treaty or a transparent data-sharing arrangement between New Delhi and Beijing.This leaves India vulnerable to two possible scenarios: sudden releases of large volumes of water from upstream reservoirs could trigger floods in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam, while diversion or reduced winter discharge to fill China’s reservoir could affect the Brahmaputra’s flow downstream.Chief minister Pema Khandu has repeatedly flagged the absence of a binding water-sharing arrangement and transparent data-sharing mechanism with China as a major concern. He has argued that SUMP’s proposed storage capacity of about 9.2 billion cubic metres (BCM), higher than the reported 5.2 BCM of the Chinese project, would give India greater capacity to regulate flows, respond to changes in discharge and sustain lean-season water availability if Beijing reduces downstream releases.However, local opposition remains strong, with indigenous organisations and residents raising questions over the project’s environmental and social costs, seismic vulnerability and what they describe as inadequate consultation.In a memorandum emailed to Shah on Friday, the Adi Bane Kebang United and the Siang Indigenous Farmers’ Forum sought a halt to pre-feasibility work, release of detained protesters, withdrawal of central forces and a judicial inquiry into the October 23 violence.The organisations alleged that the project was revived in 2024 without proper consultation and pointed to what they described as contradictory statements by Khandu and MP Tapir Gao. While expressing support for discussions and indicating a preference for smaller dams, they made it clear that talks could not take place in the presence of armed personnel.The Centre now faces the challenge of reconciling the project’s strategic and energy-security imperatives with the apprehensions of communities whose land, livelihoods and cultural heritage could be affected by its implementation.
