CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court has dismissed a petition filed by the Union government challenging a tribunal order granting higher grade pay to employees appointed as Supervisor Barrack and Store in the Military Engineering Service (MES), holding that similarly placed employees in the same cadre cannot be given different pay benefits.A division bench of Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi and Justice Minderjeet Yadav upheld the July 7, 2026, order of the Chandigarh bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), which had directed the authorities to grant the employees grade pay of Rs 4,600 in Pay Band-2 instead of Rs 4,200.The court noted that the employees were appointed in July 2018, when the upgradation of the post from grade pay of Rs 4,200 to Rs 4,600 had already been approved by the President of India on December 15, 2017, and the benefit had been extended to other personnel in the cadre. The upgradation was subsequently kept in abeyance in October 2018.However, the bench held that this could not retrospectively deprive the employees of a benefit they were entitled to when appointed. “Once, on the date when they were appointed, the post was in the grade pay of Rs 4600 which benefit had already been extended to all the personnel working in such cadre, merely subsequent to the appointment that the upgradation of the post of Barrack and Store was kept in abeyance cannot be made applicable upon the respondents herein,” the court observed. “Any order kept in abeyance can only be made applicable prospectively and not retrospectively,” it added.The post of Supervisor Barrack and Store was advertised on January 6, 2015, with a prescribed pay scale of Rs 9,300-34,800 in Pay Band-2 and grade pay of Rs 4,200. Before the selection process was completed, a cadre review resulted in the post being upgraded to grade pay of Rs 4,600, with the President’s approval communicated on December 15, 2017.While the revised benefit was extended to other personnel in the cadre, those appointed in July 2018 against the 2015 advertisement continued to receive grade pay of Rs 4,200. Their representations were rejected on May 9, 2019, following which they approached the CAT. “Once, even after keeping in abeyance the upgradation of pay-scale in the post of Supervisor Barrack and Store in October 2018, the benefit of upgradation already given to the employees is being continued to be enjoyed by them, arguing before this Court that such benefits should not have been given to the respondents, is incorrect,” the bench observed.It said the tribunal’s direction was valid and removed the anomaly of granting two different grade pays to similarly situated employees in the same cadre. The court also clarified that even if the original upgradation was beyond the authorities’ jurisdiction, the government would have to withdraw the benefit from all employees receiving it, rather than selectively denying it to the petitioners.
