Kolkata: Conversions happen because of deprivation when the state fails to fulfil its responsibilities towards its people, several civil society and Christian community members said at a roundtable titled ‘Religious Conversion in Secular India’ in Kolkata on Friday.Arpan Rana, representing the National Christian Council, said Christian missionaries have provided education and healthcare to people in remote and deprived places, but never bargained religious conversion in exchange for the services.“Christians are a minority among minorities in India. If the Christian missionaries had been converting people to Christianity for providing education and healthcare, our population would not have been so small after 200 years,” Rana said at the roundtable, held at Bharatiya Bhasa Parishad on Shakespeare Sarani.A representative of Bangiya Christiya Pariseba, a platform representing Christians of all denominations, said the Constitution gave all the right to practise and propagate one’s religion.Rajen Raja, one of the speakers, countered the argument put forward by many civil society workers. “If you say conversions happen because of deprivation, then you are actually taking advantage of people’s plight. You are offering them help and using it to convert them to another religion,” he said.“I admit there are issues of deprivation. But the govt is precisely objecting to conversion. There is nothing wrong if the govt makes attempts to stop conversion,” he said.Friday’s roundtable came against the backdrop of BJP state president Samik Bhattacharya saying religious conversions won’t be allowed in Bengal. “Many Christians are part of the BJP family. Hindus, Muslims and Christians all have a place in this land and we can work with everyone. But conversion will not be allowed in Bengal,” Bhattacharya had said.Amitabha Dutta, a social activist, said large-scale religious conversions took place in the British era when Adivasis converted to Christianity. “Are Adivasis Hindus or are they a separate religion? Is such a comment an attempt to re-convert them to Hinduism?” he asked.Many of the participants said there was no forced conversion and if there is forced conversion, the Christian community would support legal action against those responsible. “False narratives are being spread to build a narrative that people are consuming,” said Kaushik Maitra of National Christian Council.
