‘Riot victims deserve sympathy & empathy’: HC orders Punjab govt to restore plot to 1984 survivor | Chandigarh News


‘Riot victims deserve sympathy & empathy’: HC orders Punjab govt to restore plot to 1984 survivor

Chandigarh: Directing Ludhiana Improvement Trust (LIT) to restore a 40-square-yard plot allotted to a 1984 Delhi riots victim, which was cancelled in 1992 for non-payment, Punjab and Haryana high court has said that riot victims “deserve sympathy and empathy”.The division bench of Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri and Justice Pravindra Singh Chauhan also imposed Rs 50,000 in costs, to be paid equally by the state and LIT. HC termed the state’s rejection “totally cryptic”, arbitrary and violative of the Constitution.“While passing orders, particularly in cases involving persons who have suffered under extraordinary circumstances, the authorities are expected to exercise due care and diligence and should not reject the claims of riot victims in a casual or routine manner,” the bench observed in the recent order.“Riot victims deserve not only sympathy and empathy, but their rights under Article 21 of the Constitution of India also get severely impaired if caution and prudence are not adhered to. Therefore, the state should be extremely careful in dealing with such cases,” it added.The petitioner, Mohinder Singh, was allotted a plot in the 475-acre Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar Scheme in Ludhiana under Sikh Migrant Quota on Aug 12, 1987, for Rs 3,520. He was required to pay the amount within 30 days, either in full or by depositing one-fourth and paying the balance in instalments. He was unable to pay because of extreme poverty after the riots, and his allotment was cancelled in 1992.His request for a second chance was rejected in 2007. In 2015, Punjab govt offered defaulting allottees a one-time opportunity to deposit outstanding charges, including interest, penalty and deemed restoration charges, and get their allotments regularised. But Singh’s request was again rejected on Nov 24, 2015, citing failure to deposit 25% of the price within 30 days and a delay of 23 years.He approached high court. His counsel, S S Salar, argued that the policy covered allottees whose plots had been resumed or cancelled. He said the plot was still vacant and the petitioner was ready to pay the requisite amount with reasonable interest.Punjab AAG Raghav Goel submitted that the case was not covered by the policy, and Advocate Manbir Singh Batth for LIT argued that the cancellation had been communicated and there was a considerable delay in filing the writ petition.The bench held that default in payment could not be used to deny the petitioner benefit of the very policy framed to address such defaults, pointing out that the 2015 policy covered allottees who had not paid even after expiry of the deadline.On the delay, the court noted that Singh had been approaching the authorities from the beginning and the policy prescribed no time limit for seeking its benefit. “Once the petitioner is admittedly a riot victim, he could not have been non-suited on the ground of delay,” the bench observed.On LIT’s objection that Singh had not mentioned his poor financial condition in his application, the bench said that being a riot victim, “it was not necessary for him to have proved his bad economic condition”.HC set aside the cancellation order and directed LIT to restore the plot and deliver possession. The petitioner was told to pay the allotment price prevailing in 1987, with simple interest at 10% per annum, within 30 days of LIT’s order regarding resumption. The exercise must be completed within two months.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *