CHANDIGARH: Panjab University’s AC Joshi Library has a lift, a dedicated facility for students with disabilities and assistive equipment listed in its official handbook. The university has also scored a perfect 20/20 for disability-related facilities in the National Institutional Ranking Framework (NIRF). Yet, all three approach routes to the library prevent wheelchair users from reaching the building independently.For a university whose 2023 accessibility audit found that not one of the 99 buildings surveyed was completely accessible, the question is simple: what good are facilities inside a building if wheelchair users cannot reach its entrance independently?A ground-level assessment of the three routes to the university’s central library, conducted with 24-year-old Jyoti Negi, an MA Philosophy student from Rohru in Himachal Pradesh, found no hassle-free route for wheelchair users. Negi has a locomotor disability and scoliosis and uses a wheelchair full-time. Despite using an electric wheelchair, she remains dependent on friends to reach the library.The contradiction is particularly stark in PU’s 2025 Handbook of Information, which lists a dedicated ground-floor facility at AC Joshi Library for students with disabilities, equipped with assistive devices and software. The university scored 20 out of 20 under the NIRF parameter for facilities for physically challenged students in 2024 and retained full marks in its 2025 submission.The first approach, from the Gandhi Bhawan side, has a gate near the roundabout that usually remains closed. Opening it was difficult even during the visit. Cars are regularly parked outside, further restricting access. A guard said the gate had been installed to prevent vehicles from parking outside the library, although cars continue to be parked there. The route also becomes inaccessible after around 8.30 pm, when barricades near the Department of Evening Studies block access towards Gandhi Bhawan.The second approach, from the Examination Hall side near the vice-chancellor’s office, involves negotiating a damaged road and scores of two-wheelers parked along the way. Permanent barricades at the end have narrow, zigzag gaps through which pedestrians can pass. A footpath on the right has no ramp to access it, nor is there a way to get off it near the library.The third approach, from the Student Centre, offers little relief. The direct road from Gandhi Bhawan remains closed by gates, while alternative routes pass through damaged parking areas. The tiled pathway towards the library is broken at multiple points. At its end, two pillars have been constructed directly on the ramp leading to the library corridor, obstructing wheelchair movement.“There is a lift inside the library, but how am I supposed to reach the building independently? I have an electric wheelchair and still depend on my friends to get there. Imagine the difficulty for someone using a manual wheelchair,” Negi said.The deficiencies are not new. A December 2023 accessibility audit by Delhi-based organisation Samarthya surveyed 99 university buildings and found that none was completely accessible. It flagged shortcomings in ramps, washrooms, tactile pathways, Braille signage and accessible footpaths.The university subsequently received Rs 5.21 crore under the first phase of its accessibility project to upgrade eight buildings. However, only Rs 2.12 crore was utilised, while Rs 3.09 crore remained unspent and was returned. The larger proposal to upgrade 16 buildings is estimated to cost Rs 54-55 crore.For Negi, the existence of a lift and assistive facilities inside AC Joshi Library does not translate into independent access. The three approaches demonstrate that accessibility cannot end at a building’s entrance or be measured merely by the facilities listed in a handbook. Students must be able to reach those facilities without having to depend on friends for something as basic as entering their university library.
