HYDERABAD: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on Saturday called for a balanced and responsible approach to the use of Artificial Intelligence in legal education, cautioning that technological advancement should not undermine academic integrity, independent reasoning and the ability of future lawyers to apply legal principles.Addressing the inaugural session of a two-day international conference organised by the Commonwealth Legal Education Association (CLEA) in Hyderabad, he said clinical legal education should be an integral part of the law curriculum.He proposed making legal aid work compulsory for every law student before graduation, with additional academic credits for those undertaking more service.The conference, the first international edition organised by CLEA, is themed “Globalising Legal Education: Reimagining Law Schools, Legal Learning and the Future of the Legal Profession for a Commonwealth in Transition — Tradition in Thought, Transformation in Learning”.The event began with a welcome address by justice EV Venugopal of the Telangana high court and chairperson of the CLEA organising committee, and Prof (Dr) S Sivakumar, president of CLEA.The CJI said completely banning AI tools would be neither practical nor wise, as the technology had already become part of professional and academic life.The priority, he said, should be to establish clear rules for their use and ensure students understand the difference between using technology as an aid and allowing it to replace their own thinking.Justice Surya Kant also expressed concern over the growing reliance of educational institutions on software designed to detect AI-generated content.Referring to a study that found widely used AI detectors wrongly identified more than three in every five essays written by non-native English speakers as machine-generated, he said an honest student could be branded a cheat based on a machine’s finding.“No student should be held guilty of misconduct on the word of a machine alone,” he said.He suggested supplementing written assessments with oral explanations, defence of legal authorities and exercises to identify errors in AI-generated answers. He also urged CLEA to develop model guidelines on disclosing AI assistance in legal research for adoption by law schools and journals across the Commonwealth.Referring to Prof NR Madhava Menon’s vision, the CJI said legal education should take students beyond classrooms and connect them with people in need.He recalled Menon’s efforts to promote legal clinics for the poor and said these should provide actual assistance rather than remain limited to formalities or awareness programmes.Supreme Court judge and CLEA patron justice PS Narasimha cautioned that excessive dependence on AI could weaken law students’ ability to think independently, reason and exercise sound judgment. He said the process of learning law was as important as the final outcome.“While AI could help address complex issues and improve the delivery of legal services, its greatest risk lay in replacing human thinking rather than merely assisting it,” he said.Acting chief justice of the Telangana high court P Sam Koshy said the conference theme was timely and consequential, as it invited participants to look beyond the conventional understanding of legal education as the teaching of statutes, precedents and procedural rules.“The future of the Commonwealth’s legal tradition will not be secured by merely preserving its past; it will be secured by its capacity to learn, adapt and evolve without losing its foundational principles — laws may be enacted by legislatures, interpreted by courts and administered by governments, but the future of law is ultimately shaped by those whom we educate to understand, question and uphold it,” justice Koshy said.Telangana advocate general A Sudarshan Reddy said the state government was introducing 10 new subjects, including cyber laws and cyber security, and emerging technologies and law, into the undergraduate law curriculum.“The inclusion of these subjects is academically justified and aligned with global best practices in legal education,” he said. He added that while legal education, the practice of law and the tools available to lawyers were changing, “what remains unchanged are, most importantly, the expectations of society from the legal profession, and foundations of profound learning and honour, which our institutions are built upon.”Solicitor general of India Tushar Mehta and attorney general for India Dr R Venkataramani also addressed the gathering. Chief justices and judges from various high courts, vice-chancellors, deans, senior academics, practitioners, researchers and legal educators attended the event.
