Jaipur: In a landmark victory for road accident victims and grieving families, a full bench of Rajasthan High Court has ruled that interest awarded on Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) compensation is not taxable “income” and cannot be subjected to tax deducted at source (TDS) by insurance companies.The three-judge bench—comprising Chief Justice Sanjay K Agrawal, Justice Sameer Jain and Justice Bhuwan Goyal—delivered the judgment on Nov 18, resolving years of conflicting legal interpretations across the state.The reference arose after HDFC ERGO General Insurance deducted TDS from the interest component of a compensation award granted to Satya Narayan, Dhapu Bai and an 11-year-old minor, Kumari Ritika, following a fatal accident.Agrawal emphasised that compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act is rooted in the principle of restitutio in integrum—an effort to restore victims or their dependants to the financial position they would have held had the tragedy never occurred.“Because the principal compensation replaces a destroyed source of livelihood rather than generating profit, it is a capital receipt, not income,” said the court.Consequently, simple interest awarded under Section 171 from the date of the claim petition until the final award or appellate judgment is an “integral, inseparable, and inalienable” part of that restitution, merely offsetting inflation and litigation delays.The court overruled its own earlier precedents, notably Sharda Pareek and Kailash Narain Gupta, aligning Rajasthan with Bombay, Gujarat, Madras, Karnataka, Punjab & Haryana and Odisha High Courts.The bench clarified that without underlying taxable income, insurers have no authority to withhold TDS under Section 194A.Furthermore, the court highlighted that Parliament has already cemented this relief under the new Income Tax Act, 2025, via the Finance Act, 2026.“Effective April 1, 2026, any MACT interest received by an individual or legal heir is unconditionally tax-exempt and free from TDS deductions, ensuring every rupee of court-ordered relief reaches bereaved families intact,” the court said.
