Delhi man with critical stroke waits 5 hours to be shifted from hospital, family arranges ambulance themselves, consumer commission orders Rs 15 lakh compensation for deficient service | Delhi News


Delhi man with critical stroke waits 5 hours to be shifted from hospital, family arranges ambulance themselves, consumer commission orders Rs 15 lakh compensation for deficient service
The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission found Metro Hospital responsible for deficient service concerning a stroke patient.

NEW DELHI: The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed a city hospital to pay Rs 15 lakh in compensation for failing to arrange a life-support ambulance and a doctor to accompany a critically ill stroke patient during his transfer to another hospital.Holding Metro Hospital & Heart Institute in Lajpat Nagar guilty of deficiency in service, the commission said the hospital had failed to meet even the elementary standards of reasonable care and medical responsibility expected of a healthcare institution.However, in an order dated November 6, the commission rejected allegations of medical negligence against the treating cardiologist, ruling that the treatment administered to the patient was in accordance with standard medical protocols.A bench comprising commission president Justice Sangita Dhingra Sehgal and judicial member Pinki allowed a consumer complaint filed in 2015 by Suresh Kumar, through his wife, against the hospital.According to the complaint, Kumar, who had undergone a double valve replacement surgery at AIIMS in 2008, was admitted to Metro Hospital on November 13, 2013, after developing acute breathing difficulties. An echocardiogram revealed a clot obstructing his artificial heart valve.The family alleged that they were only informed that an injection would be administered, without being adequately explained the associated risks. They also claimed the doctor assured them that the patient would recover within a few days.Two days later, on November 15, Kumar suffered paralysis on his right side and lost his ability to speak after a clot travelled to his brain, the complaint stated.The family alleged that the hospital then took around five hours to arrange his transfer to another facility and failed to provide an ambulance equipped with life-support facilities or a doctor to accompany him. They eventually had to arrange an ambulance from another hospital themselves.Kumar has not recovered since the incident and remains completely dependent on his family, the complaint said.The hospital denied the allegations.No negligence by cardiologist, says commissionIn examining the allegations against the treating doctor, the commission considered medical opinions submitted by boards at GB Pant Hospital, the Delhi Medical Council and the Medical Council of India.“A perusal of the aforesaid medical opinions leaves no room for doubt that the patient was managed successfully using streptokinase as per the standard medical protocol,” the bench observed.It added that “prima facie, no medical negligence can be carved out” against the cardiologist.Hospital failed in basic duty to arrange patient transferThe commission, however, found serious shortcomings in the hospital’s arrangements for shifting the critically ill patient, observing that it had “miserably failed” to discharge an elementary responsibility towards him.“The record unequivocally reflects that the hospital failed to make adequate arrangements for the transportation of the patient, thereby resulting in the wastage of precious and critical time at a juncture when the patient was in an extremely vulnerable condition and required immediate medical intervention,” the order said.The bench also took note of the hospital’s failure to offer any convincing explanation for not arranging the necessary transportation and medical supervision.It observed that a hospital, particularly one that presents itself as a premier medical institution and charges substantial amounts for treatment, cannot absolve itself of its fundamental obligations towards patient care.“The duty of a hospital does not come to an end merely on providing consultation or administering treatment within its premises,” the commission said.It further said that failing to arrange an ambulance and appropriate medical supervision during the transportation of a critical patient could not be dismissed as a procedural lapse or an administrative omission.“In matters concerning human life, precious time lost in arranging basic emergency medical facilities may have consequences which cannot subsequently be undone or compensated for,” it observed.Describing the hospital’s conduct as a “serious dereliction of the duty of care”, the commission held it guilty of deficiency in service.It directed Metro Hospital to pay Rs 15 lakh as compensation for the mental agony and distress suffered by the patient and his attendants due to the failure to provide a life-support ambulance, along with Rs 50,000 towards litigation costs, considering that the case had remained pending for more than 10 years.(With PTI inputs)



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *