Pune: Bombay high court this week held that land granted under old-grant conditions belonged to Union govt and that construction of a bungalow on such a plot did not confer ownership rights over it on the occupant.Setting aside a possession decree passed by two lower courts in a decades-old dispute involving a bungalow in Pune Cantonment, Justice Gauri Godse held that the private trust claiming ownership had failed to establish absolute title to the land. The court ruled that the eviction notice issued by the trust was invalid and that Union govt could not be treated as a tenant of the property. It clarified that the trust’s rights, if any, under the lease agreements to seek possession of the bungalow remained open.The judgment pronounced on Nov 18 in two second appeals filed by the Union of India and the Military Estate Officer, Pune Circle, brings into focus the legal distinction between the ownership of land and rights over structures constructed on old-grant properties.The dispute concerned 0.85 acres of land, including a bungalow at survey number 742 in Pune Cantonment. The T S Anklesaria Trust claimed absolute ownership of the property based on a registered sale deed executed in 1918. Union govt maintained that the land was granted under the old-grant conditions of the Govt General Order (GGO) dated Jan 6, 1827, under which govt retained proprietary rights in the soil.Examining the General Land Register (GLR), the Military Lands Manual and historical documents, the high court found that the property was classified as Class B-3 land, with the trust’s predecessor recorded only as an occupancy holder. The court explained that although a Class B-3 classification by itself did not conclusively establish govt ownership, Rule 8(ii) of the Military Lands Manual provided that such classification was used where govt had grounds to presume that the proprietary rights in the soil were retained under an earlier grant.The court noted that the land had never been reclassified as private property and that the trust had not challenged the GLR entry. It also found that the 1918 sale deed did not establish the source of the vendor’s title to the land. A sale deed, the court observed, could transfer only the valid title held by the vendor and could not confer a better title than the vendor possessed.The court further relied on the 1827 GGO. It provides that permission to construct a house within a military cantonment does not confer ownership of the underlying land and that the land continues to belong to the state and remains resumable by govt.The permission granted to the original occupant to construct an additional room, along with correspondence from the cantonment magistrate and other historical documents, also indicated that only occupancy rights had been transferred, subject to govt conditions and its power of resumption.
