‘Careers of hundreds may be hampered‘: HC orders Punjab panel to seal PCS recruitment records | Chandigarh News


‘Careers of hundreds may be hampered‘: HC orders Punjab panel to seal PCS recruitment records

Chandigarh: The Punjab and Haryana high court has directed the Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC) to preserve and seal the entire record of the Punjab Civil Services (PCS) recruitment process — from the submission of applications till completion of scrutiny on Nov 18 — and submit it to the court secretary by 5pm on Nov 23.The court has already stayed the further recruitment for 322 posts, including DSP, tehsildar and excise and taxation officer among others, under a Jan 2, 2025, advertisement that drew more than 85,000 applicants following allegations of irregularities.In his detailed order released on Friday, Justice Sandeep Moudgil observed that “if the process of selection is allowed to continue, it may hamper the career of hundreds of candidates…” “In any case, not even a single person would be allowed to be given a public appointment if he is found to be ineligible in any manner at any stage of the selection process. Even the candidates who have been shortlisted for the interview after the declaration of the result of the mains examination on Nov 4, by which not much time has lapsed, if finally given appointments, would also be in doldrums in case the writ petitions are accepted finally,” the judge observed.The HC was hearing six connected petitions challenging different aspects of the recruitment process. The mains examination result had provisionally shortlisted 751 candidates for interviews.The petitioners alleged post-advertisement rule changes and exam irregularities. These included repeatedly extending deadlines for sports and disability quota certificates, allegedly allowing 361 sports-category candidates to submit documents late and postponing the exam to give applicants extra time to clear a mandatory Punjabi language requirement.Senior advocate Amit Jhanji, appearing for the petitioners, questioned the postponement of the preliminary examination from April 2025 to Oct 26 and then Dec 7, 2025.Senior advocate Chetan Mittal, appearing for petitioners in another connected petition, pointed out 17 instances in which candidates were allegedly issued roll numbers under male and female categories. He also questioned the issuance of multiple roll numbers despite rules restricting candidates from applying for the same post in more than one category.The petitioners also raised concerns over question papers, pointing out that some carried serial numbers while others did not, and that the printing patterns and fonts differed. They argued that this raised doubts about whether question paper packets had reached examination rooms in sealed condition.Senior advocate Rajiv Atma Ram, representing the PPSC, attributed the missing serial numbers to a printing machine error.The petitioners alleged that question paper packets were not opened in the presence of candidates at examination centres 4 and 8 and that there was no live CCTV coverage of examination halls.Senior advocate Gurminder Singh Garry, appearing for private respondents, argued the petitioners challenged the process only after failing to qualify. He submitted that the careers of candidates who had qualified the mains examination should not be jeopardised and that the selection process had been conducted in a transparent and fair manner.The HC observed that the petitioners‘ challenge required examination of the records. “Without examining and testing the said argument, it would be totally unfair on the part of this court to allow the process to continue,” the HC observed.The court also listed several concerns which, it said, were prima facie glaring in nature.The Bench also took note of the petitioners’ allegations concerning the credibility of evaluators whose appointments had earlier been quashed by the Supreme Court in Mandeep Singh vs state of Punjab (2025 INSC 834), but who had allegedly been allowed to continue temporarily as guest faculty.Punjab additional advocate general TPS Walia did not oppose halting the recruitment and assured the court that the state govt was ready to give an undertaking that the selection process would not proceed further and interviews would not take place at least until Dec 15. The next hearing is on Dec 16.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *