Calcutta High Court sets aside gang rape convictions for lack of evidence, 3 walk out after 8 years in jail | Kolkata News


Calcutta High Court sets aside gang rape convictions for lack of evidence, 3 walk out after 8 years in jail

Kolkata: After spending eight years in prison for gangrape, three men from Bardhaman had their life sentences set aside by Calcutta High Court, which found no forensic or medical evidence to substantiate the minor victim’s allegations.The division bench of Justice Rajasekhar Mantha and Justice Anuj Singh, in its Nov 13 order, also expressed “surprise” at the trial court’s reasoning that “the defence did not suggest to the prosecution witness that no incident of rape had at all occurred.”The bench observed that the burden of proving charges rests with the prosecution and an accused cannot be convicted merely for failing to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, including the victim.The alleged incident occurred on the night of Aug 19, 2006, when the girl was returning home from a music programme. She alleged that the three men caught her, gagged her with her dupatta and gangraped her.Her father lodged a complaint two days later. The girl was allegedly treated by a local quack before being taken to hospital. However, she declined examination, saying she was menstruating. Her mother claimed her private parts were swollen, but no other injuries were found.The three men were arrested and charges framed on July 17, 2013. They were convicted in Oct 2018 and sentenced to life imprisonment and fined Rs 5,000.The bench observed: “It is now equally well-settled that a conviction under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code or under Sections 4 and 6 of Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 can follow on the sole evidence of a victim.”However, it said such evidence must be “of sterling quality and be supported by at least some medical evidence.”Holding that the “prosecution miserably failed”, the bench observed: “Except for recording an allegation of rape, there is no material medical evidence to show any sexual assault on the victim.”The court also noted that the victim’s clothes were neither seized nor sent for forensic examination. “It is difficult for this Court to believe that the victim was disrobed voluntarily by the appellants. There must be some resistance put up by the victim which would have damaged her clothes,” the bench reasoned.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *