A wrong decision can always be corrected, says respondent
Such projects cannot be dropped halfway after proceeding with land acquisition and payment of compensation, say judges
Chennai: Madras high court on Friday wondered how Tamil Nadu govt could suddenly abandon the massive Parandur greenfield airport project that had been approved by all authorities. “Such projects cannot be dropped halfway after proceeding with land acquisition and payment of compensation. Airports are not constructed merely on your whims and fancies,” the first bench of Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan said.Pointing out that all the requisite approvals had been obtained, the bench observed that the state govt cannot say the project is not feasible at this stage.Responding to a plea moved by G Gouthaman challenging govt’s decision, advocate-general Vijay Naryan said the decision to drop the project was announced by chief minister C Joseph Vijay in the assembly. A GO to the effect is under process and will be issued shortly, he said.He told the court that of the 5,368 acres of land required for the project, more than 201 acres are water bodies, wetlands and lands used for agriculture, considering which govt arrived at the decision. He added that it would have been difficult to obtain environmental clearance since large sections of the land are classified as water bodies and agricultural lands. A wrong decision can always be corrected, he said.Recording the submissions, the court directed the state to file its counter and adjourned the hearing to Dec 21.According to the petitioner, the decision of the state govt announced under Rule 110 of the Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly Rules is arbitrary, unreasoned and liable to be declared as unconstitutional. Govt’s decision to cancel the project fails the Wednesbury Principle of unreasonableness (established by the English court of appeal in 1948), taking into consideration irrelevant factors, such as relying solely on pre-election campaign commitments and promises made to local residents without empirical counter data while ignoring critical relevant factors, he said.The state govt has ignored the multi-agency feasibility studies by TIDCO, safety clearances by AAI and statutory in-principle approval granted by Union ministry of civil aviation, massive public expenditure of more than ₹680 crore and proven passenger bottleneck at Chennai’s Meenambakkam airport, the petitioner added.
