CHANDIGARH: At 57, with just five months left before retirement, Jai Mala is finally set to walk into a classroom as a Sanskrit teacher, 27 years after she was asked to join a Haryana government school but never received her appointment letter.The Punjab and Haryana high court on Monday directed the Haryana government to appoint her with effect from June 10, 1999, along with all consequential benefits, setting aside the judgments of two lower courts that had rejected her claim.“Though I have only five months of service left before my scheduled retirement in April, I can’t wait to step into a classroom. This is what I have been waiting for,” Jai Mala, now 57, told TOI on Wednesday.The 27-year-long fight, however, came at a heavy personal cost. Her husband, Roop Chand, said the prolonged uncertainty and repeated disappointments took a toll on her mental and physical health. She slipped into depression and also suffered a cardiac attack, he said.“We spent lakhs of rupees, suffered disappointments, but I am happy that after 27 years of struggle, justice has prevailed,” Jai Mala said.Her ordeal began in December 1998, when she was called for an interview for the post of Sanskrit teacher. In June 1999, the district education officer scrutinised her certificates and asked her to join a government school in Rewari. However, the formal appointment letter never arrived.Despite approaching the authorities repeatedly, she failed to get the letter. She eventually filed a suit seeking appointment with effect from June 10, 1999, along with arrears of salary and allowances and interest.The Haryana government opposed her claim, arguing that she had not submitted a certificate establishing knowledge of Hindi up to the matriculation standard, a prerequisite for the post. It also disputed her contention that she had studied Hindi during her BA.The dispute centred on her educational qualifications. Jai Mala held BA and B.Ed degrees, with Sanskrit and English as subjects. She had also studied Hindi in both Part-I and Part-II of her BA.A trial court dismissed her suit on May 18, 2006. The Rewari district judge upheld the decision on October 11, 2006, forcing her to approach the high court.Before the high court, her counsel argued that the lower courts had overlooked documentary evidence showing that she had secured 106 out of 200 marks in Hindi in BA Part-I and 89 out of 200 in Part-II. Having passed Hindi at the graduation level, she possessed a qualification higher than the minimum knowledge of Hindi prescribed for the post, the counsel submitted.The state counsel maintained that the earlier judgments were based on a proper appreciation of the facts.The high court, however, found merit in Jai Mala’s argument. Justice Manuja observed that the documentary evidence clearly established that she had studied Hindi during her BA.Referring to Haryana government’s instructions dated June 16, 1979, and a Supreme Court judgment, the court held that a higher academic qualification in the prescribed subject could not be disregarded merely because she had not studied Hindi at the matriculation level.“Once the appellant-plaintiff acquired higher academic qualification in the very subject for which knowledge was prescribed, the mere fact that she had not studied Hindi at the matriculation level could not, by itself, have rendered her ineligible for the post,” Justice Manuja observed.The court also took note of the authorities asking her to join the school before withholding the formal appointment order.“The respondents’ conduct in asking the appellant to join and thereafter withholding the formal appointment order lends support to her case, reflecting a lack of due diligence on their part,” the bench said.With the high court ruling in her favour, Jai Mala said she was looking forward to starting work and performing her duties diligently.Her husband, who works as a computer teacher at a government college in Rewari, said their education helped them sustain the prolonged legal battle.“We could persist with this legal battle only because we are educated and understood the legal process. Otherwise, it would have been extremely difficult for an ordinary family to sustain such a long fight,” he said.
