HC: Grant-in-aid educational institutions require prior permission of competent authority for recruitment | Bengaluru News


HC: Grant-in-aid educational institutions require prior permission of competent authority for recruitment

Bengaluru: Karnataka High Court has ruled that the requirement of obtaining prior permission of the competent authority by the grant-in-aid institutions for undertaking recruitment, as prescribed under the applicable rules, continues to operate and the competent authority is entitled to examine all relevant statutory requirements before granting or refusing such permission.No application seeking permission should be rejected solely on the ground that the vacancy arose after Dec 31, 2015, or by mechanical reliance upon govt letter dated Feb 2, 2023. Any decision refusing permission should be supported by justified reasons and communicated to the concerned institution, a division bench of Justices DK Singh and H Shanthi Bhushan said in its order passed on Nov 17.The notification dated June 10, 2020, should not be construed as imposing a perpetual or continuing prohibition on filling up vacancies in aided educational institutions. The restriction under Clause 2 thereof was expressly confined to the Financial Year 2020-21 and Clause 3 thereof should be understood in the context of the said notification and the financial exigencies for which it was issued. However, it clarified that the above directions do not confer upon any institution an automatic right to fill up a vacancy or to claim grant-in-aid in respect of an appointment made against such vacancy. The requirement of prior permission and compliance with the prescribed recruitment procedure shall continue to apply. State govt is at liberty to formulate an appropriate policy governing grant-in-aid, having regard to its financial capacity, subject to such policy being consistent with the Act, the rules and the Constitution, the division bench added while partly allowing an appeal filed by state govt.BackgroundOn Dec 8, 2023, a single bench had allowed the petition filed by Karnataka Rajya Anudanitha Shikshana Samsthegala Okkoota and directed that the competent authority is bound to accord permission for filling up of posts in grant-in-aid institutions and can object only if reservation/roster is not followed.Challenging the same, state govt had argued that Section 49 of the Karnataka Education Act vests a duty on it (state govt) to set apart a sum of money annually for giving as grant-in-aid to the local authority institutions and private institutions, which is subject to the limits of economic capacity of the state. This sum of money is a matter of policy which the state alone has to decide looking into its financial capacity and other relevant circumstances.The June 10, 2020, notification made it clear that grant-in-aid benefit will not be given for any new schools and that no vacant posts of teachers would be filled in grant-in-aid schools in view of the critical financial condition of the state due to Covid-19. The single bench failed to notice the cut-off date of Dec 31, 2015, fixed by the state permitting the educational institutions to fill up the posts, state govt added.After perusing the materials on record, the division bench pointed out that the notification dated June 10, 2020, imposed a restriction in the context of the FY 2020-21, and govt letter dated Feb 2, 2023, proceeded on the premise that vacancies arising after Dec 31, 2015, cannot be filled, without disclosing the source or legal basis for such restriction.Section 52(2) of the Karnataka Education Act empowers state govt to sanction grant-in-aid or, for good and sufficient reasons, refuse to sanction such grant. The provision, however, does not expressly confer upon state govt any independent power to impose a general prohibition on the filling up of vacancies in aided educational institutions. It essentially contemplates the consideration of applications seeking sanction of grant-in-aid and empowers govt to take an appropriate decision thereon in accordance with the statutory requirements, the division bench elaborated in the order.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *