Landline dead for 2 yrs: Consumer panel orders BSNL to refund dues, pay compensation | Ahmedabad News


Landline dead for 2 yrs: Consumer panel orders BSNL to refund dues, pay compensation

Ahmedabad: A 35-year-old relationship with BSNL ended in a consumer commission battle after a Kalol family’s landline remained dead for nearly two years, even as the telecom company continued collecting advance charges. Gandhinagar district consumer disputes redressal commission has now directed Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd (BSNL) to refund the money with interest and pay compensation for deficiency in service.The complaint was filed by Chandrakant Patel, a Kalol resident who continued with the BSNL landline connection for 35 years because his 85-year-old mother and 63-year-old elder brother found mobile phones difficult to use. BSNL collected Rs 1,772 in advance in both 2023 and 2024, but the telephone remained non-functional.Repeated complaints through BSNL’s online portal, emails and written representations brought little relief. Instead, automated messages declared the complaints closed after the grievance was redressed. Even a legal notice and a newspaper report highlighting the family’s predicament failed to move the company.Patel eventually approached the consumer commission. BSNL admitted that excavation and drainage pipeline work had damaged the underground copper cable and restoring the connection was not possible in the area. It claimed that it had offered a fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) connection through its partners, with a minimum voice plan costing Rs 299 plus GST, but Patel declined. The company also offered a refund of Rs 1,200, which he rejected.The commission said BSNL could neither retain advance payments citing cable damage nor discontinue the service arbitrarily without the customer’s consent.“If the copper cable was damaged, arranging an alternative connection or restoring the service without imposing an additional financial burden on the customer was the telecom company’s primary responsibility,” it stated.The commission observed that keeping an essential landline service unavailable for such a prolonged period was particularly serious in a household with elderly members. BSNL’s failure to address complaints and resolve the grievance amounted to deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act and ran contrary to the spirit of consumer protection.It directed BSNL to refund Rs 3,542 with 9% annual interest and pay Rs 4,000 as compensation for mental agony and harassment, besides litigation costs.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *