New Delhi: Law-and-order powers cannot be used as a “blanket justification” to interfere with journalistic activities, Supreme Court has been told by the Network of Women in Media, India, which has alleged the forcible detention and assault of journalists covering protests in Delhi in Oct.The protests were called against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over alleged irregularities in the functioning of the Election Commission.In a rejoinder to Delhi Police’s counter affidavit, the petitioner said obstruction, forcible removal, assault and sexual harassment of journalists violated their personal liberty, bodily integrity, freedom of occupation and press freedom.“Journalists are routinely enabled to report even from armed-conflict and other manifestly dangerous environments, where the recognised response to risk is protection and facilitation of reporting rather than removal of the reporter,” it said.Delhi Police, in its counter affidavit, had said it held press freedom in the highest regard and sought to distinguish journalists from reel-makers at the Jantar Mantar protest.Rejecting the distinction, the petitioner said the reference to “reel-makers” appeared to be a retrospective justification for obstructing and detaining journalists.It argued that the issue was not whether police could maintain public order, but whether they could obstruct journalists performing their professional duties, in violation of Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 19(1)(d) and 21 of the Constitution.The petitioner also cited Supreme Court’s Oct 11 direction that lawyers, journalists and other professionals must not be hindered in discharging their duties.
