Shimla: A woman living separately from her husband without sufficient grounds cannot claim maintenance, Himachal Pradesh high court has held.A wife must demonstrate justifiable reasons for staying away from her husband to claim maintenance under the law, a division bench comprising Justice Ajay Mohan Goel and Justice Yogesh Jaswal observed while dismissing a woman’s petition, challenging an order of the Bilaspur family court in a maintenance case against her husband.The family court had directed the husband, who earns Rs 46,000 per month as a govt clerk, to pay Rs 5,000 as monthly maintenance to their minor son, besides bearing his educational, medical and marriage expenses. The maintenance was ordered from the date the application was filed until the child starts earning or completes his studies. However, the court had rejected the wife’s maintenance claim, holding that she was capable of maintaining herself.Challenging the decision, the wife’s counsel argued before high court that she had no independent source of income and was therefore entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. Her counsel contended that the family court had failed to consider this important aspect while deciding her claim.Opposing the petition, the husband’s counsel submitted that the wife had been living separately without any justifiable reason and had failed to establish any circumstances compelling her to stay away from him.After examining the record, the bench found nothing wrong in the findings of the family court. It noted that the wife, who was MA and B.Ed qualified, had admitted during cross-examination that she was capable of earning. The family court had also recorded findings, based on the evidence and documents, that she had physically assaulted her husband and that her aggressive behaviour had contributed to their strained relationship.The bench observed that the wife’s counsel failed to demonstrate that these findings were unsupported by the evidence on record. Referring to Section 125(4) CrPC, the court reiterated that a wife is not entitled to maintenance if she lives separately from her husband without sufficient reason. Finding no merit in the petition, the bench dismissed it.
