Shimla: A govt employee cannot be denied maternity leave merely because she has more than two surviving children, Himachal Pradesh high court has ruled, pointing out that the minimum of 12 weeks is available even for the birth of a third child.A division bench comprising Justice Vivek Singh Thakur and Justice Ranjan Sharma passed the order while allowing a petition filed by teacher Raksha Sawarwat, whose request for maternity leave after the birth of her third child was rejected by state govt.Raksha, appointed in 2002, had delivered her third child on July 24, 2017, and applied for maternity leave from Aug 11, 2017. Her request was rejected on the ground that Rule 43(1) of Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972, restricts maternity leave to women employees having fewer than two surviving children. Rejecting state govt’s stand, the bench observed that Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, provides a statutory minimum entitlement that cannot be curtailed by service rules. Section 5(3) of the Act clearly says that a woman having two or more surviving children is entitled to 12 weeks of maternity benefit.The court noted that the Act overrides any ‘inconsistent law or service conditions’. Even where CCS rules do not provide maternity leave for the birth of a third child, a woman cannot be deprived of the minimum benefit guaranteed under the Act.The high court also referred to Articles 21 and 42 of the Constitution, observing that maternity relief, the right to health, and a child’s entitlement to maternal care are integral to a humane framework of employment. The court also clarified that there was no need to strike down Rule 43(1) or the state’s 2009 office memorandum, as the Maternity Benefit Act itself provides the necessary statutory protection.Directing the authorities to grant the petitioner 12 weeks’ maternity leave and all other admissible benefits, the bench quashed contrary orders and directed the education department to calculate and extend the benefits by Dec 15.
