Margao: Bombay high court at Goa has sought responses from the respondents in a public interest litigation (PIL) challenging the 7.5 MLD sewage treatment plant (STP) under construction at Curchorem. The PIL alleges that the project, on the bank of a Zuari river tributary, has destroyed a mangrove patch and violates the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) Notification, 2011.The petition has been filed by social activists Aditya Raut Dessai and Sushant Dessai. It seeks a stay on further construction, land-levelling and commissioning of the plant, restoration of the mangroves and floodplain, and relocation of the project. It names the Union of India (Ministry of Jal Shakti), the state of Goa, Sewerage and Infrastructural Development Corporation of Goa Ltd (SIDCGL), Goa State Pollution Control Board (GSPCB) and Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (GCZMA) as respondents.Speaking to the media, Adv Seoula Vas, appearing for the petitioners, said the PIL challenges the legality of the consent to establish granted by GSPCB and the no-objection certificate issued by GCZMA. The petitioners contend that both approvals misinterpret and misapply the CRZ Notification, 2011.Vas said the STP site is close to the bank of the Zuari tributary and falls within the high tide line (HTL). The area comprises a mangrove patch and salt marsh, which, according to the petitioners, fall under CRZ-IA, a no-development zone (NDZ). The PIL argues that CRZ-IA areas enjoy stringent protection and that construction and public projects are prohibited there, except for limited activities permitted under the CRZ rules, including certain strategic and essential infrastructure of national interest.The petition says SIDCGL, the project proponent, cleared land and carried out large-scale landfilling within the HTL. It claims this has buried mangrove roots, which need tidal aeration to survive, causing irreversible damage even where the trees were not uprooted. The petitioners say the actual extent of the damage can be ascertained only through an independent, mangrove-specific scientific assessment.The PIL disputes a joint inspection by GSPCB and GCZMA on July 21, 2025. The report had said the mangroves were observed at the site and were not found uprooted, but “appeared submerged” due to land levelling. The petitioners call this finding scientifically untenable and say it was based only on visual observation, without examining historical satellite imagery, pre-project records, coastal zone management plan maps or Forest Department records.The petitioners also point out that GCZMA granted a CRZ clearance/NOC on July 6, 2026, for felling 19 mangrove trees of unspecified species, with a condition to plant three times the number cut. This, they say, came after SIDCGL applied post facto on October 7, 2025, following their complaints. They argue that no provision in law permits felling of mangroves in a CRZ-IA area and that the compensatory planting condition is arbitrary and unimplementable.The PIL seeks relocation of the plant to a site at least 200 metres from Zuari and 500 metres from the HTL, a fresh and independent inspection by GSPCB with GCZMA, and restoration of the mangroves and the filled floodplain at the cost of the agency found responsible.
