Gurgaon mayor gets relief as court dismisses appeal over caste certificate | Gurgaon News


Gurgaon mayor gets relief as court dismisses appeal over caste certificate
Earlier, Prajapati had questioned the caste certificates relied upon by Malhotra

Gurgaon: An election tribunal does not have the jurisdiction to examine the validity of a duly issued caste certificate in an election petition, a city court ruled, while giving relief to mayor Raj Rani Malhotra on Wednesday. The court dismissed an appeal — filed by Yashpal Prajapati — against her, which had challenged the rejection of an election petition against her eligibility to contest the mayoral election from a seat reserved for BC-A women.District judge Narender Sura upheld the Sept 5, 2025 order of the civil judge (senior division), which had dismissed the election petition filed by Prajapati. The petition was dismissed on the basis of jurisdiction without deciding on the allegations of the petitioner about the mayor’s caste certificate and alleged involvement of the officials. Such disputes, it said, must be addressed through the caste scrutiny mechanism established by the state govt.The dispute arose after the city mayoral post was reserved for a woman belonging to the BC-A category of Haryana. According to the election petition, Prajapati, who identified himself as belonging to the Prajapati community classified under BC-A, questioned the caste certificates relied upon by Malhotra and another mayoral candidate, Seema Pahuja, while contesting the March 2, 2025 municipal election.Prajapati alleged that Malhotra had falsely declared herself to belong to the Sunar community to obtain a BC-A certificate, despite allegedly belonging to the Punjabi Jat community. He also questioned Pahuja’s certificate, alleging that she belonged to the Punjabi Khatri community. These were allegations made by the petitioner and not findings established by the court.Malhotra contested the election and won. She was declared mayor on March 12, 2025. Prajapati approached the election tribunal seeking, among other reliefs, a declaration that Malhotra’s election was void, cancellation of the caste certificates and her removal from the mayoral office.The district judge observed that the election petition could not proceed when its central issue required the election tribunal to determine the caste status of the returned candidate, a matter outside its jurisdiction. The court also rejected the argument that the election petition should have been allowed to proceed so that the petitioner could lead evidence regarding Malhotra’s caste. It observed that allowing the proceedings to continue would serve no purpose when the tribunal itself lacked jurisdiction to decide the underlying question.“After going through the plaint, record of the case and considering the submissions made by the counsel for the parties, this court does not find any illegality in the order dated 05.09.2025 passed by the election tribunal and it is held that once the question of caste cannot be decided by the election tribunal in election petition, such election petition is required to be rejected outrightly on this point only,” observed the court.The court noted that even if the other objections raised against the election petition, including defects in verification, were set aside, the petition remained legally unsustainable because the question of caste could not be adjudicated by the election tribunal. Holding that the original tribunal had committed no illegality in rejecting the petition, district judge Narender Sura dismissed the appeal with costs on Tuesday.The judgement also records that Prajapati, along with two other petitioners, had earlier approached Punjab and Haryana High Court through a public interest litigation, raising concerns about the issuance and validity of the BC-A certificates. On Aug 25, 2025, the HC disposed of the petition, directing the deputy commissioner to decide the representation dated March 6, 2025, on its merits within 30 days after providing the concerned parties an opportunity to be heard.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *