Emaar told to pay Rs 3L compensation for delay in Rera norm violations in Gurgaon: Buyer pays Rs 22L against Rs 75 lakh, but builder-buyer agreement signed a year later in Real Estate Act violation | Gurgaon News


Emaar told to pay Rs 3L compensation for delay in Rera norm violations in Gurgaon: Buyer pays Rs 22L against Rs 75 lakh, but builder-buyer agreement signed a year later in Real Estate Act violation

Gurgaon: A developer, which took over 10% of the sale price before executing the builder-buyer agreement (BBA), was directed to pay Rs 3 lakh in compensation, besides refunding excess stamp duty with interest, to a Delhi homebuyer. Kuldeep Kumar Kohli — who bought a ground-floor unit in June 2009 — had sought compensation to the tune of over 50 lakh.In an order dated Nov 13, Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (Hrera) directed Emaar India to pay the amount for acting in contravention of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Adjudicating officer Rajender Kumar ruled on a complaint filed by Kohli, who paid Rs 22.6 lakh, against a sale consideration of Rs 75.4 lakh, but the BBA was signed for the unit in Emerald Floors at Emerald Hills in Sector 65 only on May 28, 2010. Possession, due on Aug 24, 2012, was offered in 2017 and handed over in 2018.Kohli said the flat was flooded with seepage and remained uninhabitable until March 2020, forcing him to live in rented housing. He sought Rs 5 lakh for mental agony, Rs 3 lakh as litigation costs and Rs 44 lakh as pecuniary damages, including rent. Emaar contested the complaint, arguing it was barred by limitation, that Kohli had enjoyed the unit without protest after a conveyance deed in Aug 2018 and that it had already credited Rs 21.6 lakh as delay compensation. It also cited an indemnity-cum-undertaking signed by him in 2014.An Emaar spokesperson said, “We are reviewing the recent order passed by Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA) concerning a unit at our Emerald Hills project and intend to file an appeal before Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (HREAT). The occupation certificate for the said unit was duly obtained in June 2016, followed by the handover of possession and execution of the conveyance deed in 2018. In our view, the order overlooks several critical factual and legal aspects, including the non-applicability of retrospective statutory provisions to an agreement executed in 2010 — prior to the enactment of RERA — as well as the lack of substantive evidence supporting the ancillary claims. As the matter is sub-judice and an earlier appeal concerning the same unit is already pending adjudication before HREAT, we will refrain from commenting further on the specifics and will pursue all appropriate legal remedies.”The officer accepted that an allottee who stays in the project is not entitled to compensation beyond delayed possession interest, relying on rulings of the Uttar Pradesh and Haryana real estate appellate tribunals. Since HRera had already granted such interest in an earlier complaint decided in May 2022, he said, delay alone could not found a fresh claim. But Kohli had also raised other grounds, which the officer examined separately.Under Section 13(1) of the Act, a promoter must execute and register the BBA on receiving 10% of the sale price. Kohli had paid Rs 22.6 lakh by then, which the officer termed contrary to law. On this count, he awarded Rs 1 lakh, a tentative interest on the excess, but refused Rs 4.5 lakh claimed as rent for nine months. Emaar must also refund the extra stamp duty Kohli paid for registering the conveyance deed, which he put at Rs 72,300, with 11% annual interest from the date it was collected. Rs 50,000 was granted for seepage, for which no repair expenses were proved, and Rs 1 lakh for mental agony, against Rs 5 lakh sought. Though Kohli is an advocate who argued in person, he got Rs 50,000 as litigation costs while claims over HVAT and an alleged layout change were rejected, the latter for want of evidence. All sums carry 11% interest from the order date.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *