Mumbai: A proposal to lease 4,210sqm of civic school land at Charkop Sector 2 for 30 years on a one-time premium of Rs 4.1 crore to a local educational trust has sparked a controversy. The opposition demanded its immediate withdrawal, and sought a review of the 2024 municipal school lease policy and a discussion on the issue in the BMC House.The proposal is to be tabled before the improvement committee on Wednesday.According to the proposal, St Mary Educational Trust has been occupying all 19 classrooms of Charkop Sector 2 Municipal Corporation School under a licence arrangement since 1995. The school building was handed over by Mhada to BMC.The civic administration said a policy approved in Feb 2024 by the municipal commissioner, then functioning as the administrator, allows private organisations operating schools on BMC premises under licence to obtain land on lease if they express interest in redeveloping the school building. Under the policy, such an institution must have carried out educational activities prior to 2010 and on a licence basis in a BMC school. St Mary Educational Trust expressed interest in redeveloping the Charkop school building, the proposal said.Congress BMC group leader Ashraf Azmi alleged that the proposal seeks to grant long-term rights over valuable public land to a private institution under a policy formulated during the administrator’s tenure, without adequate scrutiny or discussion by elected representatives. “Existing classroom occupation cannot justify a 30-year lease of the entire municipal land. The administration has not established why an arrangement for using classrooms should justify granting long-term leasehold rights over the entire public school property. Moreover, the proposal concerns a specific private institution without any disclosed competitive tendering or transparent public selection process,” said Azmi.He also questioned the valuation adopted by the administration, which considered a ready reckoner rate of Rs 62,280/sqm for 2025-26 and an FSI of 1. “After applying the concessional valuation formula, the proposed one-time premium is about Rs 4.1 crore. However, applying the full ready reckoner rate to the entire plot at FSI 1 gives a benchmark value of around Rs 26.2 crore. The proposal also provides for highly nominal classroom rental rates. Such concessional financial terms cannot be accepted,” he said.Congress said the policy could affect civic school properties across Mumbai by creating a framework for converting them into long-term private institutional leases. It said these properties should remain dedicated to public education, particularly for children from economically weaker sections.
