Raj HC upholds 2-year jail term for ex-ASI in 19-year-old bribery case | Jaipur News


Raj HC upholds 2-year jail term for ex-ASI in 19-year-old bribery case

Jaipur: Rajasthan High Court has held that a complainant turning hostile cannot shield a public servant accused of corruption if other oral, documentary, electronic and circumstantial evidence establishes the demand and acceptance of a bribe. The court observed this while upholding the two-year imprisonment of a former assistant sub-inspector (ASI) in a 19-year-old bribery case.A single-judge bench of Justice Praveer Bhatnagar dismissed an appeal filed by Noratmal Nolkha, the then ASI posted at Sop police station in Tonk district, on Nov 4. It upheld his conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.The court held that a hostile complainant’s testimony cannot be discarded in its entirety and that portions corroborated by other evidence can be relied upon. Referring to a Supreme Court Constitution Bench judgment in Neeraj Dutta vs State (NCT of Delhi), it reiterated that demand and acceptance of illegal gratification can be established through circumstantial evidence even if the complainant turns hostile or becomes unavailable.“Mere aspersions, which are always spat out over the witnesses to defend, cannot brush aside their oral, documentary and other circumstantial evidence,” the court observed while rejecting the defence challenge to the credibility of prosecution witnesses.Appearing for Nolkha, advocate Mahendra Sharma argued that the prosecution had failed to establish the demand and acceptance of the bribe, as complainant Om Prakash Bairwa had turned hostile and denied the allegations. He also questioned the authenticity and admissibility of recorded conversations, citing the absence of a Section 65-B certificate with the chargesheet and the lack of a voice sample of the accused.He further challenged the prosecution sanction and the ASI’s authority to submit a negative final report.The HC, however, found that the recorded conversation, its transcript, recovery of currency notes, FSL report and testimonies of independent witnesses collectively established the offence beyond reasonable doubt.The ACB had alleged that Nolkha demanded Rs 1,000 from Bairwa for submitting a negative final report in a criminal case against him and his father. He allegedly accepted Rs 300 on March 24, 2007, while the remaining Rs 700 was recovered during an ACB trap the following day.The HC upheld the trial court’s Dec 24, 2019, conviction and sentence, directing Nolkha to surrender forthwith to serve the remaining imprisonment. Both two-year sentences will run concurrently.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *